Quote:
Originally Posted by dabong1
I think either the media are totally fabricating the story or there is some truth in it.
I think we can say she existed and that she was handed to the US.
Would you agree to the above.
|
No. I would only agree that she existed. Whether she was handed to the US, noone has proven. It's just as likely that she was murdered and someone is using it for their own agenda, than she was arrested off the streets and is being held in Guantanomo.
Quote:
|
Yeah it is possible,but nobody has pointed to that direction ,so i am inclined to take yvonne ridleys word and mozzam baigs over the US army version of events......who have a track record of BS.
|
Why would the US or anyone else focus in that direction, when they don't even know who Ridley is talking about? It's like you telling me that Satan or Shaytaan exists, since i don't deny it, or give another explanation for a bad event, then it must be that he exists. It's utterly illogical.
The US cannot disprove or offer an alternative explanation because they don't know what on earth Ridley is on about. And I'm inclined to agree with their position.
Though the US has come out with proven BS, so have the Mullah FM's, Ridley, and Moazzem Begg, none of whom have actually seen this person. Why would I take their words for it then?
Possibly a relation, for example. A lover? A drunk tramp? It could be just about anything? For sure homicides do happen in Pakistan.
Quote:
|
Only a few arabs knew about torture in iraq carried out by the US but it turned out to be true.
|
The Arabs were pretty quiet about the torture in fact. The torture only came to light when some US soldiers reported the incidents to newspapers.