Indian (BHEL) made power plant breaks down in 2 weeks

[freddiemaize]

Originally Posted by eastwatch

You have once again proved yourself to be a nut by selling an old plant to BD. Don't worry, you will not be paid unless you take the plant back to your poor dirty country and then install a new one.

You call him a nut but you people even failed to find out that they have insatlled a old but panited stuff in your country (if what you say is true). Also, the viticm is nut and not the one who cheeted

[M_Saint]

Originally Posted by sarthak

Well , weird things keep hapenning in your country. We have plants made by BHEL which have been working for like 20-30 years.

Weird effects at step-brother like neighbor's land whereas 20-30 yrs live-span on own's demonstrate that two products aren't same. Is it hard to understand? Foxieering of IND has gone up to that magnetude that it has been showing new stuff during sales speech whereas delivering junk after securing the deal. In last AWAMY dalal's tenure, Maruti had made headway to BD's market by similar pattern and purchasers of those junks became penniless after their investment started to ruin on streets with the break down of shinny India's cars.

[Ingis]

There isn't a single credible media outlet which has backed this claim.

Post one and then only this thread will taken seriously.

[PeacefulIndian]

Can't find anything about breaking down of the plant.

Steel Guru : BHEL installs 120 MW gas turbine unit in Bangladesh

It is reported that the 120 MW gas turbine generating unit at Siddhirganj Power Plant in Bangladesh set up by Bharat Heavy Electricals was inaugurated by Mr Sheikh Hasina PM, Government of the Peoples Republic of Bangladesh.

This is the first unit of the prestigious 240 MW Siddhirganj Peaking Power Plant Project being set up by BHEL on turnkey basis. The second unit is also in an advanced stage of completion at the Asian Development Bank funded project of the Electricity Generation Company of Bangladesh.

BHEL has earlier set up the 100 MW Baghabari Power Plant in Bangladesh which has been operating successfully for almost a decade. The commissioning of this 120 MW unit at Siddhirganj Power Plant marks another milestone in further strengthening India Bangladesh trade and economic relations.

Electricity generated by the Siddhirganj power plant will provide the much needed addition to the installed power generating capacity of Bangladesh. For the project, the scope of work awarded to BHEL by EGCB, Bangladesh includes complete design, manufacture, testing, supply, installation and commissioning of 2 numbers 126 MW ISO rated Gas Turbines and Generators along with auxiliaries and Gas Booster Compressors, besides other major equipment and civil works.

Major equipment like gas turbines, generators, gas booster compressors, generator transformers as well as state of the art control systems were manufactured by BHEL at their various plants in India. For the civil as well as erection commissioning and other local works, local companies in Bangladesh were associated.

Bangladesh has been a key export territory of BHEL, where in the past, it has successfully executed several contracts including the 100 MW Baghabari Gas Turbine Power Plant; 230 kV Baghabari Substation and extension of the existing 230 kV Ishurdi Substation, besides supply of Power Transformers, HT Motors and Oilfield equipment to various industries in Bangladesh.

BHEL has a rich and varied experience of supplying and installing over 1, 00,000 MW of power plant equipment and has established its footprints in all the six continents of the world, spanning over 70 countries. BHEL’s technical competence has earned worldwide acclaim and the company is taking long strides to become a major global player by further enhancing its presence in international markets.

[PeacefulIndian]

I think I have found it.

http://www.e-bangladesh.org/2010/02/...omment-page-1/

PM Hasina inaugurated operation of Gas fired Siddhirganj Power Plant only 8 days ago. Gas supply to hundreds of industries of Rupganj and part of other Narayanganj areas were kept suspended to allow gas supply to Siddhirganj Power plant of Indian Company BHEL. Even then due to low gas pressure the plant operation has been shut down.

The reason is low gas pressure, does not have anything to do with BHEL equipment....
I pity BD people who get brainwashed so easily. Anything anti-India without an iota of truth sells so easily.

[Ingis]

Originally Posted by PeacefulIndian

I think I have found it.

Energy situation in Bangladesh




The reason is low gas pressure, does not have anything to do with BHEL equipment....
I pity BD people who get brainwashed so easily. Anything anti-India without an iota of truth sells so easily.

Great find! The article clearly says that the plant had to shut down because of low gas pressure.

Maybe some of these Bangladeshis were thinking that the BHEL turbines could run without fuel.

This is the height of idiocy.

[PeacefulIndian]

How incompetent BHEL is !!!!!!!

We can not even make power plants that run without fuel

[Goodperson]

Originally Posted by PeacefulIndian

How incompetent BHEL is !!!!!!!

We can not even make power plants that run without fuel

Kindly replace BHEL with India as usual practice for India bashing.

[iajdani]

At the time of commissioning and test run there will be a lot of adjustment and readjustment. Even a simple compressor or a bad wiring could bring the plant to a complete shutdown. A power plant is a complex machine. Please be patient. It will be just fine.

[M_Saint]

Originally Posted by sarthak

I'm pretty sure the plant broke down because the people in your poor dirty country don't any knowledge about handling a power plant. Probably a kid studying for IIT has more knowledge than the best mechanical engineers in your country

During my staying in Wayne State's (Wayne State University) dorm with BUET's Mechanical engineers, I eargerly asked if Indians were far more aptitude than them. They negated with many funny stories, one of which was a friend of mine got 99 percentiles in VECTOR MECHANICS along with other Bangladeshis close to his whereas IIT and other Indian products fell far behind. But seeing BUET's rating, Indians claimed that our students cheated. So came the next one and BUET's products outscored Indians again to shut their mouth up. The reason to cite it just to let you know that your deeds don't match with your words. A close relative of mine is one of the best in 'Steel Engineerings' in our Sub-continent who used to be in good list of even TATA. We have fallen behind because of the stoppage of the flow of industrialization but that doesn't mean that our DNA has changed.

[jha]

we really are stupids..how come we expected the rich neighbor to supply gas for their own electricity....when they have the technical know how of producing electricity from thin air...

No gas supply and its a BHEL fault

[PeacefulIndian]

Originally Posted by M_Saint

During my staying in Wayne State's (Wayne State University) dorm with BUET's Mechanical engineers, I eargerly asked if Indians were far more aptitude than them. They negated with many funny stories, one of which was a friend of mine got 99 percentiles in VECTOR MECHANICS along with other Bangladeshis close to his whereas IIT and other Indian products fell far behind. But seeing BUET's rating, Indians claimed that our students cheated. So came the next one and BUET's products outscored Indians again to shut their mouth up. The reason to cite it just to let you know that your deeds don't match with your words. A close relative of mine is one of the best in 'Steel Engineerings' in our Sub-continent who used to be in good list of even TATA. We have fallen behind because of the stoppage of the flow of industrialization but that doesn't mean that our DNA has changed.

That's the difference right there, you know. Comparing a couple of people from BD with couple of people of India - and proclaiming how intelligent or dexterous BD people are........ Taking an incident out of nowhere involving Indian students - does not really stand up in any form of argument.

Nobody in this world cares about anybody's potential.....only results matter.

[fateh71]

Originally Posted by eastwatch

Excuse me, do you understand the word 'Commission?' This low grade BHEL plant was knocked down at the commissioning stage. What can we expect out of a poor and technologically inferior country called India!

Dirty poor technologically inferior, devoid of humanity blah blah bhah blah blah.....

All indian members, pls help report his posts, there is no reason we have to tolerate a hate mongers verbal vomit. His posts have nothing to do with the (fake) topic and he's just abused all indians in a (fake) case involving one indian company. This is against the forum rules.

[Ingis]

Originally Posted by M_Saint

During my staying in Wayne State's (Wayne State University) dorm with BUET's Mechanical engineers, I eargerly asked if Indians were far more aptitude than them. They negated with many funny stories, one of which was a friend of mine got 99 percentiles in VECTOR MECHANICS along with other Bangladeshis close to his whereas IIT and other Indian products fell far behind. But seeing BUET's rating, Indians claimed that our students cheated. So came the next one and BUET's products outscored Indians again to shut their mouth up. The reason to cite it just to let you know that your deeds don't match with your words. A close relative of mine is one of the best in 'Steel Engineerings' in our Sub-continent who used to be in good list of even TATA. We have fallen behind because of the stoppage of the flow of industrialization but that doesn't mean that our DNA has changed.

Wayne State University?!

Sorry to be rude... but what is the engineering ranking of Wayne State?

It is quite interesting to know the fact that BUET's top brass go to Wayne State.

[su-47]

Originally Posted by M_Saint

During my staying in Wayne State's (Wayne State University) dorm with BUET's Mechanical engineers, I eargerly asked if Indians were far more aptitude than them. They negated with many funny stories, one of which was a friend of mine got 99 percentiles in VECTOR MECHANICS along with other Bangladeshis close to his whereas IIT and other Indian products fell far behind. But seeing BUET's rating, Indians claimed that our students cheated. So came the next one and BUET's products outscored Indians again to shut their mouth up. The reason to cite it just to let you know that your deeds don't match with your words. A close relative of mine is one of the best in 'Steel Engineerings' in our Sub-continent who used to be in good list of even TATA. We have fallen behind because of the stoppage of the flow of industrialization but that doesn't mean that our DNA has changed.

There will be brainiacs and dumbasses in every country. So comparing a smart guy and an idiot from different countries doesn't represent anything. You'll see many Americans who cant spot USA on the world map. But are all American's dumb? If so, how did they become the leading nation in the world?

My grandfather is one of the best hydro-electric specialists in India and was on Jacques Piccard's team in Switzerland in the 60s. His son, my uncle, is one of the most in-demand civil engineers in Kerala, specialising in high-cost apartments. He has also undertaken projects in middle east and Thailand. I don't go around comparing them to average Bangladeshis to prove Indians are better. Besides, you shouldn't count the brainpower of people working in other countries. Their contributions help the country they stay in, not the one they originate from.

No one has doubted Bangladesh's potential. But talking of untapped potential is like talking about helium deposits on the moon. Its is just a lot of gas until efforts are made towards tapping them and producing results!