Flintlock
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2007
- Messages
- 6,176
- Reaction score
- 0
I have been rather harsh towards the Islamic rulers
Let me just say, to balance things out, that the caste system played an equally important, if not greater role, in ensuring that Hindu society remained ignorant and weak.
Infact its the rigid caste system itself that brought innovation and science to a grinding halt in ancient India, thus turning it into an inward-looking, ignorant society that was unable to defend itself when the time came.
This is what Naipaul thought about the effect of the caste system:
Caste he finds still dominates life in India, serving to imprison "a man in his function," rendering "millions faceless." A businessman's function is to make money by whatever means he can; he does not have a duty though to produce good quality items. It is not an issue of dishonesty or of short-sightedness, as service is not an Indian concept. He described groups of sweepers who cleaned a set of stairs; after they worked with twig brooms, rags, and buckets of dirty water, the stairs and wall are not only not cleaner but dirtier than ever. However they fulfilled their function, which was to sweep, or rather to be sweepers. Actual cleanliness was not the issue. Indians have been known to be picnicking on the banks of a river while someone drowned, not lifting a finger to help. He writes that the Indians do not lack courage or an admiration for it, but rather see courage and the choice to risk one's life to save another the function only of soldiers. Attempts to save government jobs for untouchables is not lauded, as this merely in many Indian's eyes simply puts responsibility into the hands of those unqualified - by their caste - to perform that function. Those who buck the caste system, or are outside of it, such those Indians who were born overseas, are not accepted by the system and often frustrated.
It just goes to show what happens if any damaging dogma takes hold of a society.
But I think reformers like Ambedkar, Vivekananda, Rammohun Roy and others effectively ended the debate regarding the caste system, and today everyone accepts that it was a theory that was very damaging for hindu society.
Let me just say, to balance things out, that the caste system played an equally important, if not greater role, in ensuring that Hindu society remained ignorant and weak.
Infact its the rigid caste system itself that brought innovation and science to a grinding halt in ancient India, thus turning it into an inward-looking, ignorant society that was unable to defend itself when the time came.
This is what Naipaul thought about the effect of the caste system:
Caste he finds still dominates life in India, serving to imprison "a man in his function," rendering "millions faceless." A businessman's function is to make money by whatever means he can; he does not have a duty though to produce good quality items. It is not an issue of dishonesty or of short-sightedness, as service is not an Indian concept. He described groups of sweepers who cleaned a set of stairs; after they worked with twig brooms, rags, and buckets of dirty water, the stairs and wall are not only not cleaner but dirtier than ever. However they fulfilled their function, which was to sweep, or rather to be sweepers. Actual cleanliness was not the issue. Indians have been known to be picnicking on the banks of a river while someone drowned, not lifting a finger to help. He writes that the Indians do not lack courage or an admiration for it, but rather see courage and the choice to risk one's life to save another the function only of soldiers. Attempts to save government jobs for untouchables is not lauded, as this merely in many Indian's eyes simply puts responsibility into the hands of those unqualified - by their caste - to perform that function. Those who buck the caste system, or are outside of it, such those Indians who were born overseas, are not accepted by the system and often frustrated.
It just goes to show what happens if any damaging dogma takes hold of a society.
But I think reformers like Ambedkar, Vivekananda, Rammohun Roy and others effectively ended the debate regarding the caste system, and today everyone accepts that it was a theory that was very damaging for hindu society.