What's new

Search results

  1. S

    What the British thought Jinnah wanted for declassified folder DO 142/476- Jinnah had Islamist and pan-Islamic ambitions

    This thread will discuss the above. This is related to this thread here. https://pdf.defence.pk/threads/historical-evidences-for-the-arguments-as-to-what-sort-of-pakistan-the-founding-fathers-wanted.768690/ I wanted to open up a thread where we could present historical evidence for the...
  2. S

    Historical records of Iqbal’s works regarding what sort of state Pakistan was supposed to be

    This thread will discuss the above. This is related to this thread here. https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/historical-evidences-for-the-arguments-as-to-what-sort-of-pakistan-the-founding-fathers-wanted.768690/ I wanted to open up a thread where we could present historical evidence for the...
  3. S

    Historical records of Jinnah’s speeches, interviews, and letters after partition

    This thread will discuss the above. This is related to this thread here. https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/historical-evidences-for-the-arguments-as-to-what-sort-of-pakistan-the-founding-fathers-wanted.768690/ Historical evidences for the arguments as to what sort of Pakistan the founding...
  4. S

    Historical records of Jinnah’s speeches, interviews and letters pre-partition but after Lahore resolution

    This thread will discuss the above. This is related to this thread here. https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/historical-evidences-for-the-arguments-as-to-what-sort-of-pakistan-the-founding-fathers-wanted.768690/ Historical evidences for the arguments as to what sort of Pakistan the founding...
  5. S

    Historical evidences for engagement of Islamic scholars by the government after Pakistan was founded and while Jinnah was alive

    This thread will discuss the above. This is related to this thread here. https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/historical-evidences-for-the-arguments-as-to-what-sort-of-pakistan-the-founding-fathers-wanted.768690/ These are the rules for this thread:- 1) we want to quote only primary sources. If...
  6. S

    Historical evidences for the arguments as to what sort of Pakistan the founding fathers wanted

    I wanted to open up a thread where we could present historical evidence for the arguments related to what sort of Pakistan the founding fathers (primarily Jinnah and Iqbal for now) wanted. Clearly, we do have disagreements on this topic. So I wanted to create a thread where we could discuss this...
  7. S

    What did Jinnah want- a poll?

    It seems like we are unclear about definitions of what a Muslim state is and what an Islamic state is. I offer 4 categories below. Please pick one closest to what you believe and if you have another category in mind, post in the thread the nuances there of and feel free to write a sliding...
  8. S

    Why are we buying Russian oil crude if we can’t refine it?

    Excuse me PDM lot, can you please explain when we developed the refining capacity to refine Russian crude oil? I thought we could not refine Russian oil at least that’s what you all said when PTI was in the last phase to acquire it. When did we develop the refining capacity or are we going to...
  9. S

    Why the ethnic hate recently?

    I have noticed that recently we have had a lot of posts that have been ethnic centric and racist. These have been leaving a bad taste in the mouth for readers like me. Mods, what is the forum policy on posts like this? I am not saying that a little bit of competition is bad, we can...
  10. S

    Noam Chomsky on IK

    Noam Chomsky says he would vote for IK. That removing him was not justified. Also, let me state here that even though the top public leftist intellectual in the world has said that he would vote for IK, this will not affect leftists like Hoodboy in our country. This is because they are not...
  11. S

    Why has literally every single toshakhana article been posted on this forum and a new thread been created for each article?!

    Genuine question- I do not remember seeing this many threads for Nawaz Sharifs 11 volume JIT but every single article on IK’s toshakhana needs a different thread to be posted?! Can the moderators please stop the shit posting on this forum?
  12. S

    Remittances down in May from last month and last year

    So looks like Dawn is trying to bury the news but remittances are down significantly this May from last month and indeed from last year. This govt is in trouble. They will not be able to keep remittances at same level as PTI. May 2022:- $2.332bn Compared to April 2022:- $3.125bn May 2021:-...
  13. S

    Sharif wants to borrow 36bn$ while servicing debt is 12-15 bn$ only!!!

    Even article says debt liability is 21 bn$. But this is bullshit too- this includes liability they plan to roll over from Saudi, UAE and China. Another words they want an extra 20 bn $ above liabilities to give lollipops to awam while screwing their future to win elections in the next year...
  14. S

    What’s the point of having to 2/3rds majority in NA?

    So I don’t quite understand the strategy here. Even if PTI get 2/3rds in National Assembly in re-election, they won’t be able to pass any constitutional amendment because they also need 2/3rds in Senate. Joint session can only be used for regular bills and not constitutional amendments, so...

Back
Top Bottom