Indian Brahmos missle crashes in Mian Channo

[GumNaam]

It was a long wiat.... I can tell.

Now seriously, how far do you think airliners travelled in those 2 minutes? I have travelled on that highway quite often & I can report that North-South flights are not too far removed from its alignment. So, saying that AD waited seems meaningless in context. I question the wisdom of firing a SAM which has a range of hundreds of kilometers when there are airliners in vicinity (airliner 0.7-0.8 Mach, missile 3-4 Mach).

Had it been hit directly, it would likely not be in a single piece or impact the way it did.

it's not a question of how fast the airliners were going but a question of how fast brahmos past them all came into an area where the airliners wouldn't be under any threat by the intercepting missile(s). hence why the position of the airliners is so important in knowing the true picture of what happened. all we know is that there were two intl airliners (ksA and Qatari) and 3 domestic airliners on the route. where were they, how far apart were they, how far were they from mian channu are all important but unanswered questions.

 

[NA71]

It’s not healthy to translate geopolitics into rape fantasies. Well, it’s not healthy to translate ANYTHING into these fantasies, but I digress. Carry on.

I’m glad cooler heads prevailed despite such an unfortunate event. I’m still uncertain how to accurately assess this accident - and I think it would just be wise to wait and see how both sides continue to react/respond.

O come on... Few western news outlets and analysts also skeptical about ""technical malfunction"" thing. It was well planned and executed move from Indian thinkers.

There were clear intention behind ...there are no of questions to be answered

It listed a set of questions and issues in this regard, which it said must be answered by the Indian authorities. The questions are as follows:

• Explanation of the measures and procedures in place to prevent accidental missile launches and the particular circumstances of this incident.
• Explanation of the type and specifications of the missile that fell in Pakistani territory.
• Elaboration on the flight path/trajectory of the accidentally launched missile and how it ultimately turned and entered Pakistan.
• Was the missile equipped with a self-destruct mechanism? Why did it fail to actualise?
• Were Indian missiles kept primed for launch even under routine maintenance?
• Why did India fail to immediately inform Pakistan about the accidental launch of the missile and waited to acknowledge it till after Pakistan announced the incident and sought clarification?
• Explanation if the missile was indeed handled by its armed forces or some rogue elements given the profound "level of incompetence".

Questions taken from Dawn
Courtesy : https://www.dawn.com/news/1679603

 

[Ghessan]

So you are you Talha Ahmed ??

proves the point many journalists, youtubers or twitteraties follow PDF for info.

i'm not pointing at you @Khan vilatey but we have seen half baked stories taken from this forum being posted by people on social media.

 

[HRK]

If our AIr defense units dont cover whole country so does indian . What is stopping us to retaliate?
UN dont give a damn about this incident .
india says no to our joint investigation offer . They most probably wont share the reports. ( Or to be honest how hard it is to do the drama of investigation?)
.
.
Why cant we return the favor and send something to the desert of rajistan or gujrat? What is stopping us?

exhaust all the official and legal resources before act on your own for any such provocation in future

 

[NA71]

What we did after detection ?
.
Oh wo dekho kiya missile ja raha ha ....

we did a serious presser after 24hrs.

 

[HRK]

proves the point many journalists, youtubers or twitteraties follow PDF for info.

i'm not pointing at you @Khan vilatey but we have seen half baked stories taken from this forum being posted by people on social media.

Talha is actually know his stuff .... I have hot seen him doing any BONGI (don't know what will the translation of this in eng.) on his twitter account.

 

[GumNaam]

Crater was more than 12 feet deep ..... there was a video in which a rescue worker was standing in this crater

that rescue worker in the crater doesn't look like he is 12 feet deep...and he isn't even standing up, dude is actually sitting down! it does look 12 feet wide though.

 

[Ghessan]

Talha is actually know his stuff .... I have hot seen him doing any BONGI (don't know what will the translation of this in eng.) on his twitter account.

of course,
in my post i already told him i did not point at him

 

[Crystal-Clear]

exhaust all the official and legal resources before act on your own for any such provocation in Future.

I bet thats what we said after Islamabad incident.
.
.

 

[khansaheeb]

I am not a believer in doomsday scenario. Even if Brahmos could somehow be made nuclear capable by cramming it with a miniature nuclear device, it still does not mean that lives of millions of Pakistanis are at stake. Have some balance man. Calmer professionals are at work & therefore I imagine that hyperventilation is not our policy response.

It was a doomsday scenario and yes there latest Brahmos that flies at Mach 6 is nuclear capable. You know it is wrong to assume and this is why should stop assuming:-

Assume​

to make an *** out of u and me.
verb. To believe something is true based upon general unproven observations and reports.
Coining up a foolish, humorous insinuation about somebody or something that is probably not valid.
To make a complete idiot out of yourself or another person by saying that something happened that didn't.

 

[NA71]

It is also being reported that Pakistan is waiting for the Indian inquiry results and which will also be supporting the "Tech Malfunction" thing....as a consequence, we might see some announcement from Pakistan including Pakistani Air Space closure for India till further notice.

 

[GumNaam]

If our AIr defense units dont cover whole country so does indian . What is stopping us to retaliate?
UN dont give a damn about this incident .
india says no to our joint investigation offer . They most probably wont share the reports. ( Or to be honest how hard it is to do the drama of investigation?)
.
.
Why cant we return the favor and send something to the desert of rajistan or gujrat? What is stopping us?

I think it's the OIC summit. india chose this time our purpose as this summit is too important for Pakistan and other global powers to cancel our delay. We may see some form of retaliation after the summit and burial of the political circus but not before. one thing is for sure though, give the near pin drop silence in the indian media, Pakistan has definitely done something right, otherwise indian godi media would've been sucking each other off in celebrations that they bombed Pakistan and nothing happened. they could've even claimed that it was some terror camp or what have you and that Pakistan removed the bodies etc. the typical mental masturbation they normally do. but nothing this time, they are pretty quiet, we did something right whether you like it or not. and that something, in my observed view, is both detection and interception...

 

[HRK]

that rescue worker in the crater doesn't look like he is 12 feet deep...and he isn't even standing up, dude is actually sitting down! it does look 12 feet wide though.

yaar try to find the video it was posted I think in this thread .... it was posted right after the incident when public was present and rescue workers were just reaching at the spot.

we can not see the worker in the background is standing on the bottom of crater or on something, we can see other rescue worker is coming out so the worker in the background might be waiting to come out.

don't think it as conspiracy theory but one the first things rescue agencies and authorities in that area did was to fill that crater within the night.

I bet thats what we said after Islamabad incident.
.
.

which incident .... ??? plz elaborate

 

[INDIAPOSITIVE]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1503608439335174144

https://twitter.com/x/status/1503609638197276673

https://twitter.com/x/status/1503610471630651394

https://twitter.com/x/status/1503623424916135936

 

[Crystal-Clear]

I think it's the OIC summit. india chose this time our purpose as this summit is too important for Pakistan and other global powers to cancel our delay. We may see some form of retaliation after the summit and burial of the political circus but not before.

Thats exactly what i think . Lets see. india chooses its timing wisely and i am 100% sure they won't do such stunt without the ashirwad of usa .
.
.
But atlast we have to respond in a kinetic way or else this will only encourage them to do it again next year (their general election) after a false flag.
.
.
No amount of diplomacy and baat chit could do anything .