What's new

If Kashmir blows up, all bets off: US

Why are you so worried about the rhetoric? I thought the goal #1 was to provide freedom to all of humanity, not to all minus that which hurts US-Allies.

Pakistan is so confident, we give an open challenge to all. Host a UN administered plebiscite, something to which BOTH India (India btw, ran to the UN pleading for it) and Pakistan are signatories to. Let the Kashmiris decide, simple.

If you call "Let the Kashmiris choose what they want to do" as rhetoric then A your talk about bringing freedom to the world is nothing by hypocrisy and B you're living in a fool's paradise. Even if you eliminate Pakistan, the Kashmiris would still remain there, their demand for freedom would still remain there.

You do realize that 85% of the Kashmiris want to become Independent and not join Pakistan or India. Pakistan fully supports that too, and thats what burns India and her allies right below their collective ***** as they are left no place to save face and can't spin it in any other way then.

I have a question. If Pakistan fully supports the right of Kashmiris to become independent, why is it that legislators in Pakistan's Kashmir have to swear an oath of loyalty to the accession of J&K to Pakistan?

Or am I wrongly informed and there is no such oath for anyone, legislator or government servant?
 
I have a question. If Pakistan fully supports the right of Kashmiris to become independent, why is it that legislators in Pakistan's Kashmir have to swear an oath of loyalty to the accession of J&K to Pakistan?

.........and why NE Kashmir is gifted to China??

That was a part of Kashmir, how dare Pakistani govt. use it as a private property??
 
.........and why NE Kashmir is gifted to China??

That was a part of Kashmir, how dare Pakistani govt. use it as a private property??

Who the hell are you to decide which part belongs to who? I'm sorry, next time we will acquire your prior consent before taking any decision. What's wrong with you people... Always nagging and whining about the most irrelevant issues. Never at peace. I mean, just look at your imaginative signature. You have a negative and imaginative mindset. Get out of your anti-China syndrome.
 
Last edited:
Who the hell are you to decide which part belongs to who? I'm sorry, next time we will acquire your prior consent before taking any decision. What's wrong with you people... Always nagging and whining about the most irrelevant issues. Never at peace. I mean, just look at your imaginative signature. You have a negative and imaginative mindset.

So now it has become "most irrelevant" issue for you??

Kashmir is a disputed territory, and you say that 85% of Kashmiris want independence (from both) then why on earth Pakistan should have the right to donate part of Kashmir to it's (not Kashmir's) friend.
Nobody asked Kashmiri people if they want NE-Kashmir be handed over to China....

You blame India of occupying Kashmir..but you have sold it's pieces..
But most Pakistanis still act like they are the honest side regarding Kashmir
 
So now it has become "most irrelevant" issue for you??

Kashmir is a disputed territory, and you say that 85% of Kashmiris want independence (from both) then why on earth Pakistan should have the right to donate part of Kashmir to it's (not Kashmir's) friend.
Nobody asked Kashmiri people if they want NE-Kashmir be handed over to China....

You blame India of occupying Kashmir..but you have sold it's pieces..
But most Pakistanis still act like they are the honest side regarding Kashmir

Well, let's not blow things out of proportion. You certainly have a talent for doing so.

We have a no-man's undemarcated border land, hence no question arises of any part of Kashmir being transferred. Again, you're distorting the facts.
 
Aksai Chen was uninhabited and desolate when an agreement was made with China over the territory, keeping in mind the fact that the region was historically considered part of the Kingdom of Tibet, and was annexed by the Dogra's. It therefore has nothing to do with the Kashmiris or Jammu for that matter. The only peoples with whom the region might be associated are the Buddhists in Laddakh.

The agreement on Aksai Chen between China and Pakistan states that final status of Aksai Chen, in case of the people of J&K choosing India, would be determined through negotiations with India, so it is by no means a 'settled issue' or 'sold land'.
 
Aksai Chen was uninhabited and desolate when an agreement was made with China over the territory, keeping in mind the fact that the region was historically considered part of the Kingdom of Tibet, and was annexed by the Dogra's. It therefore has nothing to do with the Kashmiris or Jammu for that matter. The only peoples with whom the region might be associated are the Buddhists in Laddakh.

The agreement on Aksai Chen between China and Pakistan states that final status of Aksai Chen, in case of the people of J&K choosing India, would be determined through negotiations with India, so it is by no means a 'settled issue' or 'sold land'.

Do not distort the facts Samaba is discussing about Aksai Chin was annexed from India in 1962. And Pakistan ceded part of its Kashmir to China in 1963.

Introduction

The Kashmir Valley, surrounded by some of the highest mountains in the world, is a land of immense natural beauty, as well as strategic importance.

Regarded by India as an integral part of the country and by Pakistan as "disputed territory" which is rightfully theirs, Kashmir lies at the heart of the continuing tensions between the neighbouring countries.

After India and Pakistan tested nuclear devices in May 1998, world attention focused in the summer of 1999 on the limited war in Kashmir which raised the spectre of a nuclear exchange in the subcontinent. As well as a border skirmish in 1999, the two countries have fought three wars in the past 55 years over Kashmir.


Nuclear testing has fueled tensions
The issue is complex, and arouses strong emotions on both sides of the border. The 8 million strong Kashmiri population is 65 per cent Muslim, but Hindus and Buddhists have an integral role in the culture.

Kashmir was ceded to India by the then Hindu princely ruler Maharaja Hari Singh in October 1947. Pakistan does not accept the accession as legal. India and Pakistan fought over Kashmir in 1947-48, with a temporary ceasefire being reached in 1949.

United Nations mediation in 1948 failed and the issue remains unresolved to date. To the east of the Line of Control (LOC) lies the valley of Kashmir, Jammu and Ladakh, guarded by Indian troops. To the west lies Pakistani "Azad [Free] Kashmir" which India calls the Pakistan Occupied Kashmir.

Another lesser known player in the region is China. In March 1963 Pakistan ceded the Baltistan territory in its part of Kashmir to China. Earlier, after annexing Tibet in 1950, China built a road from its Xin Jiang province through Aksai Chin in Kashmir, which led to the Indo-Chinese war of 1962.

Emerging victorious in the war, China occupied 37,555 sq km of the Kashmiri territory in Aksai Chin in the Ladakh region.


The Siachen glacier battlefield
China occupies roughly 20 per cent of the original state of Jammu and Kashmir. Thus, the effective control of the Indian state over Kashmir extends to less than half of the total area. Pakistan controls 78,114 sq km of the state.

Today, some 80,000 Indian and Pakistani soldiers face each other along the 450-mile-long LOC, in hostile territory that includes the Siachen glacier, the highest battlefield in the world.

Indian soldiers have been fighting what they call a "proxy war" against Muslim separatist groups. These include groups demanding Kashmiri independence, some allegedly supported by Pakistan, as well as Afghan mercenaries.

The Kashmir factfile serves as a guide to this conflict, with hot links to developments as reported in news.telegraph.co.uk.

Introduction - Telegraph
 
Last edited:
Do not distort the facts Samaba is discussing about Aksai Chin was annexed from India in 1962. And Pakistan ceded part of its Kashmir to China in 1963.

No intentional distortion intended - I did indeed get the names mixed up.

It was the Shaksgam valley or Trans-Karakorum Tract.

The rest should still be correct.
 

Back
Top Bottom