What's new

Making good use of Thar coal

Thar coal block 2 cost would be $27/ton. That’s very cheap.

Costly to process and transport elsewhere
Compare that with coal previous prices 80$ before crisis (which has 3-4x higher heating value)
 
I uploaded a thread on this two weeks ago.

 
The only good use of thar coal is making diesel synthetic fuel urea and petrochemicals out of it
 
,.,.,.

PM orders linking of Thar Coal Mines with railway network by March next year​


The Frontier Post

WhatsApp-Image-2022-10-05-at-9.49.05-PM-1-e1664993220747.jpeg



ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday directed the authorities concerned to link the Thar Coal Mines with the country’s railway network by March 2023.

During a meeting chaired by the prime minister, it was principally decided that the project of linking Thar Coal Mines with rail network would be jointly executed by the federal and Sindh governments.

In this regard, Prime Minister Shehbaz and Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah would sign a Memorandum of Understanding today (Wednesday).

The prime minister told the meeting that the development projects needed to be completed with the “Pakistan Speed” as the previous government had inflicted irreparable loss to the country during last four years.

He said the government was trying to revive the development course which the previous government had deliberately kept halted during 2018 to 2022.
“During our previous government, we accomplished the development projects within record period. What to talk of launching new development projects, the previous government halted the ongoing ones wasting the public money as a grave conspiracy,” he remarked.

He said with the linking of Thar Coal Mines with railway network, local coal would be used in power plants replacing the imported one.

Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif said the usage of Thar coal in power plants would help save $2 billion annually.The meeting was told that after the linking of Thar Coal Mines with rail network, the local coal would be utilized not only the power plants of Jamshoro and Port Qasim but also other power plants and industries in the country to save the public money.

The prime minister instructed the authorities concerned to accelerate the work on the said project to complete it by March 2023.Federal ministers Ishaq Dar, Ahsan Iqbal, Khurram Dastgir, special assistants to PM Jahanzeb Khan, Zafaruddin Mahmood and senior officers attended the meeting. Railway Minister Khawaja Saad Rafiq and Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah joined the meeting via video link. (APP)
 
,..,.,

IPPs bound to use Thar coal first

Khaleeq Kiani
January 6, 2023

ISLAMABAD: The National Electric Regulatory Authority (Nepra) has made it mandatory for all independent power producers (IPPs) to utilise local coal, particularly from Thar, before opting for imports that would also be contracted in Pakistani rupees.

This has been done through notification of ‘Guidelines for Procurement of Coal on Spot Basis’ issued by the regulator to ensure that procurement of coal on a spot basis is conducted fairly and transparently and is efficient, economical and provides value for money for the consumers.

The IPPs including those based on imported coal would be required to “first ensure whether local coal such as from Thar is available which can be used keeping in view plants’ technical requirement’ and they would estimate total quantity and quality to be procured in the next six months and then contact Thar Coal Energy Board (TCEB) to confirm availability from any of its blocks.

If no local coal is available which meets the desired specifications, then IPPs shall proceed with spot purchases through a transparent process by reaching out to all suppliers through advertised publications with sufficient time given for response. The publication of the advertisement shall be for monthly bidding as well as for pre-qualification of coal traders for an extended period of 3-6 months. The term of bid, whether monthly or 3-6 months, would be decided by IPPs and the “currency of contract shall be in Pakistani rupees.”

Imports are allowed only if specs do not meet plant requirements
The comprehensive Request for Quotation (RFQ) document would include all supply, quality, and payment-related details, along with the grievance redressal procedure for bidders. There would also be minimum acceptance and rejection standards of coal along with the penalty for any deviation from the required quality of coal including ash, moisture and sulphur content etc.

The tendering process would be well-documented and traceable and the quality of coal shall be determined on a weighted average basis of the complete order accepted quantity. Rejected quantity will not be part of the total weighted average.

There would be minimum eligibility criteria for bidders including a bid bond equivalent to five times the price and tendered quantity. The successful bidder would be required to either replace the bid bond with a performance guarantee of 10pc or submit an additional performance bond or guarantee of 5pc.

The IPPs are also required to pre-qualify a pool of coal suppliers for a monthly tendering or extended period of 3-6 months with two years minimum experience of commodity trading and compliance with other coal specifications.

The IPPs shall ensure that the final bid or negotiated price is competitive, market reflective and comparable with that of other power plants. Nepra would have the power to seek justification from the IPPs in case of any abnormal difference in coal prices.

The calculation of benchmark coal price would be worked out in rupees per million British thermal unit (mmBtu). Technical specifications for coal and transportation costs have also been set under the new guidelines including those relating to ship sizes, monsoon and non-monsoon period, taxes and other charges.

Minimum order for spot purchase will be 5,000 tonnes per month and the coal specifications shall be prescribed by each IPP as per its requirements. The selection and award process shall prioritise the lower quoted price irrespective of the volume committed hence enabling a pool of suppliers to complete the requested quantity on a per-month basis.

Published in Dawn, january 6th, 2023
 
Any plans to build more power plants using coal Thar? If the current energy mix uses only 10 % coal and our two largest neighbors, India and a hike are at nearly 50%, why should Pakistan also try to go to 50%. The costs seem lower and money would be circulated within the country if the technology to manufacture coal fired plants was done domestically due to the number of plants. If we are to industrialize, we need cheap electricity. Other than loans, the world isn’t going to compensate Pakistan for low carbon emissions while being disproportionately effected by climate change.

If the current mix is 35,000 MW; a further 16,000 MW would cost $24 Billion if at the same cost as the 330 MW Thar coal plant.

Going big on coal (which could have saved us the $24 Billion spent this past year importing oil and gas (so had we spend that much making coal fired plants it would have been one and done)), improving the electric grid, and selling more domestically made EVs or Hybrid EVs, could be the way Pakistan grows out of this debt problem, stronger for it. IMHO, Domestic oil and gas should only go into building up a petrochemical and pharmaceutical industry, and not be burned for electricity generation.

A potentially good investment opportunity if the government markets it correctly. If some of the carbon generated from the coal fired plants is captured, run through ammonia gas, it could be used to inject into stubborn oil well to try to recover that oil, increasing the potential for domestic oil production.


Also, any indication if the oil or gas fired plants can be converted or augmented to burn Thar coal instead of oil or gas?

We need to build 7 plants of this size; 2400 MW at $3.6 Billion each for a total of a little over $25 Billion. Should natural gas prices drop below the cost of our coal or the nation need to show it is reducing its emissions down the road, these plants can be switched to natural gas, the same way the following plant in the video is being built in Dubai.

 
Last edited:
I would convert it into diesel. Even if is more expensive than imported oil it's local product and will cut your import bill to half .

Than fix the price for next decade and watch the economy grow
 
Thar coal is high on sulphur content and requires expensive processing technologies to ensure that no environmental issues are created by using this mineral. I would focus on developing/ finding natural gas resources just like the 3 Bcf recently discovered in guddu area.
 
Can it be used for domestic fuel and thus reduce dependency on imported LPG? Clay ovens have been used since antiquity.
 

Back
Top Bottom