What's new

NSG to hold unprecedented special session to discuss India's membership

Will India get into NSG


  • Total voters
    76

danger007

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
May 30, 2011
Messages
10,007
Reaction score
-27
Country
India
Location
India
Even as Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping met in Tashkent for bilateral talks, sources say the Nuclear Suppliers Group is reconvening in Seoul after the day’s plenary session ends, for a special session at 9 p.m. that may go into the night.

“We may have to burn the midnight oil,” one delegate said, even as other sources confirmed that India’s membership is on the agenda of the NSG session. “Normally, Heads of delegation would have met briefly post dinner to approve the joint press statement that will be issued at the conclusion of the session,” one official said, adding “that they are going to meet to discuss this [India’s membership] is quite unprecedented.”

Although the meeting of the 48-member NSG is a strictly closed-door affair, diplomatic sources from several countries have confirmed their delegation head will attend the session convened by Argentinian Chairperson Rafael Grossi. Both Argentina and host South Korea have been supportive of India’s case for a membership in the past year, and delegates from both countries are understood to have worked on setting up a special formal session on Thursday evening.

Government sources believe China will raise Pakistan's case at the session, but at present India's case is the only one on the agenda.

In a series of statements this week, China has maintained that the issue of non-NPT countries like India applying for membership is not on the agenda in Seoul. But several countries are understood to have raised India’s case during the first day of the two-day plenary on Thursday. Japan is understood to have even “welcomed” India’s application, calling for it to be considered.

Ramping up efforts, the Indian diplomatic team led by Foreign Secretary S.Jaishankar has been meeting delegations from different countries, including Brazil, who have had some reservations about offering support through the day on the sidelines of the plenary in Hotel The Shilla in the hope of ensuring the membership issue is at least taken up on Thursday, or during the second session on Friday.

Diplomats cautioned against any optimism on the basis of the convening of a special session, pointing out that there may be several possible outcomes from the session. The NSG could agree to put off the decision until the next plenary next year, or at a special plenary later this year. In addition, the NSG could agree to China’s demand for a “criteria-based process”, and refer it to a committee that could involve delays as India and Pakistan’s current applications are considered, as well as the possibility of other non-signatories like Israel applying in the future.

India’s chief challenge is China, but also countries like Turkey, Ireland, Austria, and New Zealand that have expressed opposition. In order to be accepted as a member, India must ensure every NSG member is on board, as even one no-vote would scuttle its chances.

The final decision may not be known until Friday, when the NSG is expected to issue a statement on the plenary.

Meanwhile all eyes, including those of many in Seoul, are on the outcome of Mr. Modi's meeting with President Xi in Tashkent.

Besides Mr. Jaishankar, an expert in nuclear issues himself and who has served in high profile positions in Indian missions in the US, China, Russia and Japan (key countries in the NSG), the Indian team includes its top official on nuclear issues Amandeep Singh Gill, who has negotiated the details of India’s civil nuclear agreements and MoUs with countries including Canada, US, Australia and Japan in the past few years. Also in Seoul is India’s Ambassador to South Korea Vikram Doraiswami, who has served in the PMO’s of both Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh, and handled the America desk during the crucial phases of the India-U.S. civil nuclear engagement.

US, UK, France proclaim support

In the past few days, countries like the U.S., the U.K. and France have made public proclamations of support to India’s bid, calling on oth


http://m.thehindu.com/news/national...ves-through-48member-group/article8764078.ece
 
Well Chinese reaction to this development would be interesting!
 
Let's not pop the champagne just yet. There's only a 5% chance of India getting NSG membership as even one country can throw the spanner into the works. And you have China and Turkey to contend with.

It most probably will be postponed to the special session of the NSG slated to be held later this year.

If we fail now, the Congress are the ones who will pop the champagne bottles, gloating at the failure of Modi's diplomacy! Man, they're really going to go to town trumpeting this as a debacle compared to Manmohan Singh's success in consummating the nuclear treaty with the US in 2008.
 
Oh dang! Isn't this a bit premature? Maybe we should hae more detailed discussions with CHina before hammering this? But I guess this shows how much India's influence has grown.
 
Oh dang! Isn't this a bit premature? Maybe we should hae more detailed discussions with CHina before hammering this? But I guess this shows how much India's influence has grown.
Amid stiff opposition by China to India’s entry into the Nuclear Suppliers Group, France strongly backed New Delhi’s case on Wednesday, saying it will bolster global efforts against nuclear proliferation and asking the members states to take a “positive decision” in the Seoul plenary meeting.

A key member of the 48-nation grouping, France also asserted that India’s participation in nuclear control regimes will help better regulate the export of sensitive goods, whether they are nuclear, chemical, biological, ballistic or conventional materials and technologies.

“France considers that India’s entry into the four multilateral export control regimes (NSG, MTCR, The Australia Group, The Wassenaar Arrangement) will bolster international efforts for combating proliferation

“India’s participation in these bodies will help better regulate the export of sensitive goods, whether they are nuclear, chemical, biological, ballistic or conventional materials or technologies.

“In line with its active and long-standing support to India’s entry to the NSG as a full-fledged member, France calls on its members, who are meeting on 23 June in Seoul, to take a positive decision,” the French foreign ministry said in a statement.

The ministry also mentioned that strategic partners since 1998, France and India share common goals regarding the non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction and their delivery systems.



These goals were reaffirmed during the visit of the President of the French Republic to India, from 24 to 26 January 2016, it added. The French President was the chief guest at the Republic Day celebrations in New Delhi.

On Tuesday, the US White House had in a statement said India was “ready” for NSG membership and asked participating governments to support India’s application at the plenary session of NSG in Seoul starting Thursday.

China maintains opposition to India’s entry, arguing that it has not signed Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT).

However, it has been batting for its close ally Pakistan’s entry if NSG extends any exemption for India.

http://m.hindustantimes.com/india-n...s-entry-bid/story-S2m3bi7YuYJUg09qdnFNPP.html
Just conducting poll to know opinion..
 
Modi has really pushed it very very hard. China is holding out due to strategic concerns. Its a power play and Wheels of change only move slowly. Rise of India is inevitable and China / Pakistan has to learn to live with it and benefit from it.

I can understand Pakistan efforts to stop India from getting into NSG. It can seriously effect the National morale. But the question is how long can you stop India from advancing ? May be a change in thinking required
 
China publicly supporting Pakistan, but at the end it will have to budge to the new realities. India will get into NSG. Modi has lot of stakes involved in it now. He has spent his entire 2 years PM effort to get it done. It will be big blow to him if he could not make India into NSG.

Apart from that, he also said about India into UN Security council by 2019. He would left no stone unturned to get it done.
 
Does not look good for us right now. Even Brazil joined those opposing.
 
He has spent his entire 2 years PM effort to get it done.

Thats just untrue and if it were true then India is in deep doodoo. No PM of India is going to spend HIS ENTIRE 2 YEARS on India joining NSG. Its part of a much larger picture where the economy of India has primacy over issues such as the NSG.
It just so happens this MIGHT be an opportune moment to press Indias case and so he has.
The Idea that India or its PM thinks of nothing besides the NSG is patently absurd.
If not now then next year, a small inconvenience on India's trajectory.
 

Back
Top Bottom