What's new

Pakistan in talks with Morgan Stanley to integrate her stock market (PSX) with MS's systems

Viper0011.

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 15, 2011
Messages
7,253
Reaction score
26
Country
United States
Location
United States
This is not YET out in the public, but it will be in the next couple of days (Viper always brings exclusive stuff on PDF).

Pakistan's stock market (PSX) will be integrated with Morgan Stanley's systems in New York. The negotiations have happened and the integration studies were discussed during NS's visit to the US last year.

The work to integrate both systems is about to begin. MS and Pakistan's finance minister have met multiple times on this subject during last few weeks. With this integration soon to start and complete within the next 6 months, NYSE (New York Stock Exchange) will be linked to PSX (Pakistan Stock Exchange) directly and people across the US (and the globe), will be able to invest into Pakistani Securities, ETF's, FOREX and Commodity related indices and securities, just like they do today with Japanese, Chinese, Brazilian, French and London stock exchanges.

The rough estimates show that such integration would bring well over 500 billion dollars worth of new securities related investments to Pakistan (over the next 5-7 years). The PSX has already become one of the top 5 best ROI stock markets in the past three years throughout the globe.

Some of these details should be out in the media in the next 72 hours, so keep watching your tv's and read news paper. Let me know what they post.

@WebMaster @Irfan Baloch @Horus @Oscar @Ammara Chaudhry @Jango @Desert Fox @DESERT FIGHTER @MastanKhan @araz @Atanz @Abaid Ur Rehman1 @Ababeel @babar afzal @Zee-shaun @Khafee @RiazHaq @volatile @wiqi21 @ Muhammad Omar @Major Sam
 
3023.jpeg


Quite honestly, if this is true, that's a huge win for Nawas Sharif. Having said that, practically, I don't actually know what that will mean for Pakistan's economy. The numbers given seem big, but they can often be misleading and even inaccurate.

If it's true, then its still a wait and see moment, because we don't know the practical affects yet.

Give me a day to rationalize this, and I may or may not try and give a more in depth opinion on this (potential) news.

I can say one thing though, this is probably going to lead to Pakistan being reintroduced into the emerging market category, which was predicted to happen some time this year. No doubt this was planned for a very long time, perhaps before even Nawas came into power...again, if true.
 
This will be good for the stock market and FDI.
 
Quite honestly, if this is true, that's a huge win for Nawas Sharif. Having said that, practically, I don't actually know what that will mean for Pakistan's economy. The numbers given seem big, but they can often be misleading and even inaccurate.

If it's true, then its still a wait and see moment, because we don't know the practical affects yet.

Give me a day to rationalize this, and I may or may not try and give a more in depth opinion on this (potential) news.

I can say one thing though, this is probably going to lead to Pakistan being reintroduced into the emerging market category, which was predicted to happen some time this year. No doubt this was planned for a very long time, perhaps before even Nawas came into power...again, if true.

See the attached. This initial study was created to link the previous KSE-100 with India, Japan (Nikkei), Malaysia, and China. With the current government's initiative to turn Pakistan into a big global economy and create global integration for investment, saw the birth of the PSX (Pakistan Stock Exchange), so now the goals are beyond this initial study and the goal is to integrate with NYSE and not just South Asian / Regional Markets. After all, Pakistan has been one of the top 5 ROI based markets for the past 3 years.

The most recent document, I can't attach for obvious reasons. And it is also a huge document (over 1200 pages) on this entire Pakistani economy's globalization. But I've added some components below (some of the stuff is very dry, statistical testing and sampling) and some other documents and an image or two. Hopefully, that would set the credentials of this thread as to its not all talk, there are global organizations behind it and Morgan Stanley, and the World Bank is driving this with the Pakistanis. Check out table 1 below if you want to skip the dry stuff and see the statistical results between Pakistan's KSE (now PSX) and FTSE, NYSE, etc.

Also, Pakistan is already included in the TOP 16 fastest growing countries (BRICS + 11). See attached and below

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Objective of the study
The focal objective of this study was to explore dynamic linkages between US, European,
Asian and Pakistan’s stock market which may be very useful for investors,financial
institutions and portfolio managers to utilize their capital across the border in an efficient
and smart manner.

Econometrics Methodology and Data Sources

This empirical study is based on weekly closing index of five stock markets indices of
major trading partners (US, China, India, U.K, Germany) of Pakistan. The data which
was used in this study span from 1 January, 2000 to Dec 31, 2010 (Yahoo Finance). The
return of each index is computed by the following formula.

There are different econometric techniques which are used to analyze the relationship between different time series macroeconomic variables. The study focuses to explore the association among world stock markets and Pakistan’s stock market by using the following techniques. (1) Descriptive Statistics (2) Correlation Matrix (3) Johansen Co
integration tests (4) Granger Causality test.

Johansen Julises Co integration is used in the time series data. The ideal condition to use JJ technique is that the time series variables are integrated in the same order. Stationarity of macroeconomics time series has been checked with the help of unit root test. The study used Augmented Dicky Fuller test to check the unit root in time series macroeconomicsvariables.

The ADF test checks the occurrence of stationarity in an AR (Autoregressive) equation.
The AR (1) equation is written as follows
Where Yt is the time series variables. The regression equation can be written.

(Linkages of Pakistani and Global Stock Markets Page 236)

Whereis the first difference operator. This equation may be used to estimate and
testing for a unit root is equivalent to testing null hypothesis Most of the financial time series variables are stationarity at first difference. If two series are integrated of at same order, there may have a linear combination that may be
stationary without differencing.There are two methods of co integration testing. Engle Granger (1987) test and Maximum likelihood base Johansen (1988; 1991) and Johansen - Juselius (1990) tests.

Both tests check the long run association among the macroeconomic variables. The likelihood ratio
of Johansen Juselius test the number of co integration vectors in VAR system. Eigenvalue test check the null hypothesis that there is at most r numbers of co integration equation in VAR. the maximum Eigen value statistic is given by 1

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 1: Descriptive Statistics
KSE NYSE BSE SSE FTSE DAX
Mean 0.410909 0.039088 0.325421 0.166558 -0.017812 0.035978
Median 0.727541 0.244188 0.705154 0.000000 0.156427 0.339018
Maximum 13.64966 12.89389 14.07764 14.96379 13.40915 16.11623
Minimum -18.20683 -19.53480 -15.95417 -13.84131 -21.04692 -21.60969
Std. Dev. 3.738035 2.761628 3.552023 3.625219 2.674297 3.547779
Skewness -0.721553 -0.660061 -0.419698 0.203003 -0.664536 -0.267582
Kurtosis 5.877906 9.792691 5.165853 4.809623 12.34745 7.030426
Jarque-Bera 236.2333 1091.342 122.9726 78.39371 2031.676 376.7631
Probability 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000
Sum 224.7670 21.38096 178.0055 91.10697 -9.743155 19.67980
Sum Sq. Dev. 7629.205 4164.116 6888.812 7175.650 3904.917 6872.356
Observations 547 547 547 547 547 547
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Another test is based on the “trace statistic” which tests the null hypothesis of r cointegrating vectors against the alternative hypothesis of r. The test is checked by following trace value” (Kerry Patterson).“The important thing i
s to apply JJ test is the selection lag length of VAR model. The lag length is selected on the basis of AIC” (Akaike Information Criterion).
Analyzing the long run relationship among the variables, then the system of the VAR model should be converting into error correction term to account for the short run dynamics of variables from their long run equilibrium.
According to the “Granger theorem” if two time series variables are co integrated, it means that there must be at least one direction causality exist between the time series variables. JJ test and ECM only capture the long and short run dynamics of equilibrium.

Hence, the chronological Granger causality between the macroeconomics variables may be analyzed with the joint F test. The advantage of the Granger causality test is that it can check the lead and lag relationship between the variables within the sample period. This type of exercise is also made by the variance decomposition and impulse response test.
Variance decomposition and impulse response analysis accurately measure the shock of the values of one variable in a given period which arising from the same variables as well as other variables in previous periods. The equation of the impulse response function and variance decomposition is written.

Pakistan-Economy.png
 

Attachments

  • 545PB.pdf
    259 KB · Views: 0
Thanks for the tag. :)

This sounds really good and absolutely keeping an eye on this news. Pakistan's economy is on its way to rise up. Earlier this year, there was a visit of Chinese delegation to Pakistan stock exchange as well.
And it is a expedition of four different organizations. Ministry of commerce, NBP, Trade Decelopment Authority, and Pakistan Stock Exchange as well. Hopefully, it's an authentic news and if it is------surly going to help in improving Pakistan's economy.
 
See the attached. This initial study was created to link the previous KSE-100 with India, Japan (Nikkei), Malaysia, and China. With the current government's initiative to turn Pakistan into a big global economy and create global integration for investment, saw the birth of the PSX (Pakistan Stock Exchange), so now the goals are beyond this initial study and the goal is to integrate with NYSE and not just South Asian / Regional Markets. After all, Pakistan has been one of the top 5 ROI based markets for the past 3 years.

The most recent document, I can't attach for obvious reasons. And it is also a huge document (over 1200 pages) on this entire Pakistani economy's globalization. But I've added some components below (some of the stuff is very dry, statistical testing and sampling) and some other documents and an image or two. Hopefully, that would set the credentials of this thread as to its not all talk, there are global organizations behind it and Morgan Stanley, and the World Bank is driving this with the Pakistanis. Check out table 1 below if you want to skip the dry stuff and see the statistical results between Pakistan's KSE (now PSX) and FTSE, NYSE, etc.

Also, Pakistan is already included in the TOP 16 fastest growing countries (BRICS + 11). See attached and below

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Objective of the study
The focal objective of this study was to explore dynamic linkages between US, European,
Asian and Pakistan’s stock market which may be very useful for investors,financial
institutions and portfolio managers to utilize their capital across the border in an efficient
and smart manner.

Econometrics Methodology and Data Sources

This empirical study is based on weekly closing index of five stock markets indices of
major trading partners (US, China, India, U.K, Germany) of Pakistan. The data which
was used in this study span from 1 January, 2000 to Dec 31, 2010 (Yahoo Finance). The
return of each index is computed by the following formula.

There are different econometric techniques which are used to analyze the relationship between different time series macroeconomic variables. The study focuses to explore the association among world stock markets and Pakistan’s stock market by using the following techniques. (1) Descriptive Statistics (2) Correlation Matrix (3) Johansen Co
integration tests (4) Granger Causality test.

Johansen Julises Co integration is used in the time series data. The ideal condition to use JJ technique is that the time series variables are integrated in the same order. Stationarity of macroeconomics time series has been checked with the help of unit root test. The study used Augmented Dicky Fuller test to check the unit root in time series macroeconomicsvariables.

The ADF test checks the occurrence of stationarity in an AR (Autoregressive) equation.
The AR (1) equation is written as follows
Where Yt is the time series variables. The regression equation can be written.

(Linkages of Pakistani and Global Stock Markets Page 236)

Whereis the first difference operator. This equation may be used to estimate and
testing for a unit root is equivalent to testing null hypothesis Most of the financial time series variables are stationarity at first difference. If two series are integrated of at same order, there may have a linear combination that may be
stationary without differencing.There are two methods of co integration testing. Engle Granger (1987) test and Maximum likelihood base Johansen (1988; 1991) and Johansen - Juselius (1990) tests.

Both tests check the long run association among the macroeconomic variables. The likelihood ratio
of Johansen Juselius test the number of co integration vectors in VAR system. Eigenvalue test check the null hypothesis that there is at most r numbers of co integration equation in VAR. the maximum Eigen value statistic is given by 1

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Table 1: Descriptive Statistics
KSE NYSE BSE SSE FTSE DAX
Mean 0.410909 0.039088 0.325421 0.166558 -0.017812 0.035978
Median 0.727541 0.244188 0.705154 0.000000 0.156427 0.339018
Maximum 13.64966 12.89389 14.07764 14.96379 13.40915 16.11623
Minimum -18.20683 -19.53480 -15.95417 -13.84131 -21.04692 -21.60969
Std. Dev. 3.738035 2.761628 3.552023 3.625219 2.674297 3.547779
Skewness -0.721553 -0.660061 -0.419698 0.203003 -0.664536 -0.267582
Kurtosis 5.877906 9.792691 5.165853 4.809623 12.34745 7.030426
Jarque-Bera 236.2333 1091.342 122.9726 78.39371 2031.676 376.7631
Probability 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000
Sum 224.7670 21.38096 178.0055 91.10697 -9.743155 19.67980
Sum Sq. Dev. 7629.205 4164.116 6888.812 7175.650 3904.917 6872.356
Observations 547 547 547 547 547 547
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Another test is based on the “trace statistic” which tests the null hypothesis of r cointegrating vectors against the alternative hypothesis of r. The test is checked by following trace value” (Kerry Patterson).“The important thing i
s to apply JJ test is the selection lag length of VAR model. The lag length is selected on the basis of AIC” (Akaike Information Criterion).
Analyzing the long run relationship among the variables, then the system of the VAR model should be converting into error correction term to account for the short run dynamics of variables from their long run equilibrium.
According to the “Granger theorem” if two time series variables are co integrated, it means that there must be at least one direction causality exist between the time series variables. JJ test and ECM only capture the long and short run dynamics of equilibrium.

Hence, the chronological Granger causality between the macroeconomics variables may be analyzed with the joint F test. The advantage of the Granger causality test is that it can check the lead and lag relationship between the variables within the sample period. This type of exercise is also made by the variance decomposition and impulse response test.
Variance decomposition and impulse response analysis accurately measure the shock of the values of one variable in a given period which arising from the same variables as well as other variables in previous periods. The equation of the impulse response function and variance decomposition is written.

View attachment 298723
Thanks for the pdf, it's a bit heavy on the data, so it'll take me a while to do a full reading on it. I'll probably give a more thorough explanation in a day or two.
 
This is a good development, great effort to put Pakistan back on the map. I would say that with the implementation of CPEC the timing is excellent to link PSX to global leading bourses.
 
Wonderful news @Viper0011 please keep us updated about this. The prospects for returns after such a deal are indeed impressive.
 
This is really an important development from Economics point of view .From a Country standing point of view few things which reflects country performance and Investment info is based on these factors.Main factors are Fed Reserves (State Bank having Dollars) ,GDP Growth ,CPI , Exports and Stock Exchange .

Linking stock with Morgan Stanley for trading should be a cautious move with certain checks and floorings in place in order to make this stable other wise it is a good move and shows how vibrant Inshallah our economy will be in coming days.

Word is Cautious and smart not to manipulate with us
 
What impact will this have on Pakistan's foreign exchange reserves? Will there be controls placed on these foreign investments? If I'm a foreign investor and Pakistan stock market tanks, can I easily withdraw my money from Pakistan?
 
Wonderful news @Viper0011 please keep us updated about this. The prospects for returns after such a deal are indeed impressive.

There have been many such wonderful "announcements" regarding such financial revolutions. Who remembers the $42 billion coming from UAE? Now it is $46 billion coming from CPEC. Next is $500 billion from direct securities purchases:

"The rough estimates show that such integration would bring well over 500 billion dollars worth of new securities related investments to Pakistan (over the next 5-7 years)."

Ahan. Right.
 
Last edited:
Since Viper has gotten himself banned, i'll clarify.

Morgan is considering adding PSX to their emerging markets index. This is slightly different from what Viper had stated. The latest news on this topic is below and there are still no indications of when a final decision may be reached.

This change, if it was to happen, would mean that if I purchase the MS Emerging Market Index, a small portion of that index will be made up of Pakistani securities.

Ishaq Dar reviews progress on draft Companies Bill 2016
 

Back
Top Bottom