What's new

Pakistan’s maritime compulsions

fatman17

PDF THINK TANK: CONSULTANT
Joined
Apr 24, 2007
Messages
32,563
Reaction score
98
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Pakistan’s maritime compulsions



By: S M Hali | November 21, 2012



Pakistan’s maritime compulsions are myriad; its geostrategic location, the blue-water navy ambitions of its eastern neighbour, the presence of international naval forces in its vicinity and the onset of piracy add to the challenges. With a 960-kilometre long coastline stretching to 200 nautical miles of the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) and 95 percent of its trade and 100 percent of its oil imports being transported via the sea route, make the maritime sector the bedrock of its national economy.

The close proximity to the Strait of Hormuz, the lifeline of the world’s energy needs, with more than 17 million barrels of crude oil passing every day, makes Pakistan’s location extremely sensitive. With growing strains in the US-Iran relations and Tehran’s threats of blocking the Strait of Hormuz, Pakistan’s commanding situation at the mouth of the energy highway enhance its importance.

The Indian aspirations for achieving the status of a blue-water navy in pursuit of its global power aims, has prompted it to induct a nuclear submarine from Russia, build its own nuclear subs, and acquire aircraft carriers as well as frigates and destroyers. This massive build up in its own backyard, make it imperative for Pakistan to take stock of its maritime compulsions.

Renowned naval strategists like Alfred Thayer Mahan have predicted that the Indian Ocean is an area where much of the economic and strategic dynamics of the 21st century will be played out. Its importance in the world order as well as international economy, security and stability has steadily increased after the end of the cold war. The region today is an arena of contemporary geopolitics, as through its turbulent waters the highest tonnage of goods in the world with nearly 65 percent of the earth’s oil and 35 percent of the gas located in the Indian Ocean littoral passes. The Russian as well as Central Asian States continue vying to reach the Indian Ocean’s warm waters. The war in Afghanistan makes it a hotbed for maritime operations by various international navies. The new US Strategic Guidance 2012 has linked the US economy and security to developments in the Indian Ocean, elevating India to the position of a long-term strategic partner serving “as a regional anchor” in the region. The Indo-US collusion in the Indian Ocean has made Pakistan and China wary of their semi-hostile overtures. One of the aims of US naval forces’ presence in the Indian Ocean is to deny China the freedom of movement in the region.

Additionally, the non-traditional and asymmetric challenges of maritime terrorism, piracy, narco-arms and human trafficking remain rampant in the region that further complicates its security matrix. The advent of the Somali pirates has made the waters of Indian Ocean highly susceptible to attacks and holding crew members for ransom.

All these compulsions make it imperative for Pakistan to delineate its cardinals and maintain and develop a balanced navy, aspiring to provide a safe and secure environment for maritime economic activities in the north Arabian Sea and deter any would be aggressors.

With this mission statement, the Pakistan Navy (PN) is continuing to develop a trained and motivated human resource to man and operate a potent navy capable of defending the state’s maritime interests, promote strong ties with its allies and contribute in nation building particularly in the coastal areas.

Since 2004, the PN is participating in the multinational coalition Task Force 150 and is an integral part of multinationals Task Force 151 to combat Somali piracy. In the realm of defence diplomacy, it supports foreign policy objectives through regular exercises with foreign navies and participates in flag showing in various international ports. It has come to the beck and call of Pakistan and international theatres of operations affected by natural calamities like floods, cyclones and other disasters.

In its endeavours towards nation building, the PN has established hospitals and educational institutions in the coastal region as well as played its due role in developing ports. The deep-sea Gwadar Port, in the close proximity of the Gulf, is one such enterprise that can contribute to Pakistan’s economy. However, a shard of controversy has marred it. The PN, which had legally acquired a 584 acre tract of land at Shambha Ismail near Gwadar, has been asked to vacate it. According to official sources, the navy is willing to do so in national interest provided it is allotted alternative property.

The maritime compulsions of Pakistan make it imperative to pay full attention to its naval assets and take cognisance of the threats to its sea lines of communication.

The writer is a political and defence analyst. Email: sultanm.hali@gmail.com
 
To be frank first it should take care of solving internal problems and then dream of countering India and NATO in IOR . Until then investing in offensive naval power would be waste of resources .
 
To be frank first it should take care of solving internal problems and then dream of countering India and NATO in IOR . Until then investing in offensive naval power would be waste of resources .

To be frank lozzz :laugh: on you. Pakistan Armed Forces does not think like Indian Army, okay amigo. They always plan for the future not for the nex day or so, the future, ok amigo.
 
It would be interesting to see what PN's acquisitions are in next 5 years,
are those Oliver perry hazard class frigates still on track?
 
Notwithstanding all that may be said of the advantages its location I feel the greatest drawback for the PN shall always remain its small coastline.

It offers little or no options and runs the risk of blockade with few options to ease out of. Gwader is an option but PN will have to earmark considerable resources to attempt to ensure that its sea lanes remain open, leaving little for offensive actions.

Its for PN to devise its war plans but they do not look good for want of options. The safety of ports like most pieces of land lies more from outside than within. Hence options are needed.

For the record..Andhra Pradesh has a coastline of 972 kms , Gujarat is 1600 km & Kerala is 1014 kms .
 
why? you guys were getting 4 additional free ships, how did that deal go sour?

Pakistan-US relations ... :) Well , OHP frigates are of little use in combat operations since most of their equipment are downgraded or stripped ...

Notwithstanding all that may be said of the advantages its location I feel the greatest drawback for the PN shall always remain its small coastline.

I do not agree ... Pakistan is very close to the Persian Gulf , from where the majority of world's oil is exported from ... I actually see it as an advantage because PN has to field fewer assets to defend its coastline / EEZ ...
 
I do not agree ... Pakistan is very close to the Persian Gulf , from where the majority of world's oil is exported from ... I actually see it as an advantage because PN has to field fewer assets to defend its coastline / EEZ ...

This is a POV.

What use is the proximity to the gulf to a Navy who spends a major part of its meager assets to defend its home port (s) ?

PN is not in a position to influence anything in the gulf in a hot war situation. In any case , in such a situation it shall be torn between defending its sea lanes & port. Loss of one undoes the other.
 
No , however a further 4 F22P's with improved SAMs and other capabilities are ordered ...

No? There is no pool of retired OHPs waiting and only few OHPs scheduled to retire each year (2-3?), plus there are other takers (e.g. Taiwan is intested in 8 to replace its even older ex-USN Knox frigates): it will take some time for any additional OHPs to become available. Also, I suspect PN is evaluating experiences with PNS Alamgir and there may be some budget scarcity (in which case money should properly be funneled into new ship and only into stopgaps if and when absolutely unavoidable)

To be frank first it should take care of solving internal problems and then dream of countering India and NATO in IOR . Until then investing in offensive naval power would be waste of resources .

Yeah, that surely will help reduce the duration of any foreign military presence .... :hitwall:
 
No? There is no pool of retired OHPs waiting and only few OHPs scheduled to retire each year (2-3?), plus there are other takers (e.g. Taiwan is intested in 8 to replace its even older ex-USN Knox frigates): it will take some time for any additional OHPs to become available. Also, I suspect PN is evaluating experiences with PNS Alamgir and there may be some budget scarcity (in which case money should properly be funneled into new ship and only into stopgaps if and when absolutely unavoidable)

Well , it seems highly unlikely now given the latest downhill in US-Pak relations ... Besides that , I do not think OHP Types are good choices for the PN unless of course they are coming free of cost ... Besides that , the downgrading of its SAM and other systems means that it is more suitable for anti-piracy role than in naval warfare ... However , these retired frigates are in service with a couple of navies around the world and with a few retiring every year , there's no shortage of them to supply to US allies , which we aren't considered one now ...
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom