What's new

Pakistan’s economic fortunes now in the hands of the IMF

Is more devaluation of PKR warranted?

  • Yes

  • No

  • Don't Know


Results are only viewable after voting.

Hephaestus

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Dec 6, 2012
Messages
1,173
Reaction score
-2
Country
India
Location
Australia
With Pakistan’s foreign-currency reserves falling 29% this year to US$12.6 billion by the end of October and the country’s trade deficit ticking ever upward, Islamabad has found itself back at the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to discuss a bailout.

First on the IMF’s checklist is devaluation of the Pakistani rupee. The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) loosened its grip on the currency on December 8, resulting in a downward adjustment in its exchange rate in interbank and open market transactions. It quickly shed over 5% against with the US dollar. Discussions regarding policy-level measures are ongoing.



With Pakistan’s foreign-currency reserves falling 29% this year to US$12.6 billion by the end of October and the country’s trade deficit ticking ever upward, Islamabad has found itself back at the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to discuss a bailout.

First on the IMF’s checklist is devaluation of the Pakistani rupee. The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) loosened its grip on the currency on December 8, resulting in a downward adjustment in its exchange rate in interbank and open market transactions. It quickly shed over 5% against with the US dollar. Discussions regarding policy-level measures are ongoing.

The dailyReport

Must-reads from across Asia - directly to your inbox
Pakistan’s economy had already been showing signs of floundering before it was reported in August that the central bank had borrowed $5.81 billion from commercial banks under “forward and currency swap” arrangements to boost its reserves position and stabilize the currency. Excluding those loans, Pakistan’s actual foreign currency reserves would stand at a mere $6.79 billion. And they should be excluded, because they are not usable in any sense.

“The SBP did not deny the media reports, nor did the government issue any clarification which [disputes] the apprehension that the economy has gone haywire,” a senior executive at a Dubai-based exchange company told Asia Times. Pakistan’s reserves position was particularly alarming, he added, in light of the World Bank’s estimate, in October, that Islamabad will need $17 billion worth of external financing in the fiscal year ending June 30, 2018, to service its debt payments and current account deficit.

“How the government will honor its external commitments needs to be explained,” he said, adding that as far as any IMF package is concerned, it will come with painful strings attached (for one thing, devaluation means inflation). Any “stopgap” measures, he said, would make little impact on a current account deficit of $14.4 billion, or subdue an import growth rate of $5 billion per month on the back of China’s “Belt and Road” infrastructure drive.


At the end of last month, the government launched Sukuk (Islamic bonds) and Euro bonds worth $2.5 billion, at a profit rate of 5.6% and 6.8%, respectively, again to prop up its reserves. It claimed the bidding reflected “overwhelming confidence of the global investor in Pakistan’s economy.” Independent financial analysts remained skeptical, however.

The SBP, in justifying its deregulation ploy last week, declared: “The continuation of high growth in imports led to a widening of the current account deficit, and consequently to depletion in the country’s foreign exchange reserves. These pressures have persisted, leading to an adjustment in interbank exchange rates. This movement in the exchange rate is based on demand and supply of foreign exchange in the interbank market.”

Speaking at a meeting of the Pakistan Society of Development Economists on Wednesday just after the rupee slid against the dollar, SBP governor Tariq Bajwa said the exchange rate would be determined from now on by “market forces”. The aim, he said, was for the currency to attain “equilibrium.”

In the days since, however, Peshawar’s Chowk Yadgar currency market has been directionless, with exchange companies and currency dealers hesitant to do any deals around buying or selling dollars.

http://www.atimes.com/article/pending-review-pakistans-economic-fortunes-now-hands-imf/

Bloomberg Report:
https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-12-14/politics-are-dragging-down-pakistan-economy-again

Will article 235 be invoked?
 
Islamabad has found itself back at the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to discuss a bailout.

Let us keep one thing clear: going to IMF for a bailout is a choice being made here by Pakistan, not by IMF.
 
natural equilibrium of PKR against USD is 125.
Artificially resisting the move has created huge trade deficit...

Pakistani Govt and SBP has obsession with socialist style interference in economic activity which is unhealthy and hampers growth. Pakistan should be free market capitalism where business are free to come and setup shop. If they lose, they pack up and if they win they pay taxes to the govt..
 
Okay. 2018. Finally Pakistan goes bankrupt. India wins. Kumble-Holi festival time for India.

Pakistan 1947-2018 RIP
What's India got to do with this? Your economic woes aren't India's doing.
Neither are India's economic woes Pakistan's or China's doing.
You are PDF Think Tank. Shouldn't you be more pragmatic in your comments.
 
Okay. 2018. Finally Pakistan goes bankrupt. India wins. Kumble-Holi festival time for India.

Pakistan 1947-2018 RIP

Funny.

Personally I hate the doom and gloom. Fact is that Pakistan has not seen real development since ayub era. Pakistan has struggled to create and generate income through both domestic taxes and exports. Despite recent rise in military exports, we are still unable to generate cash. CPEC is a major opportunity to grow the economy and boost Pakistan economy to the top stage however for that we will have to repair our economy. You cannot remove the damage of 2008-2013, zero energy development of 2002-2008 and of course the lost and confused governance of 2013-2018 with a magic wand.

You need strong and powerful decisions that will have long term impacts.

Again projects like CPEC don't magically generate cash flows. They are simply a step forward towards greater things. We have to take that step by repairing our economy and start generating cash so that when the benefits kick in, the cash generation increases manifold.

Maybe for once we don't think this is a global conspiracy to kill the economy and Pakistan people and do why is required which is strong and prudent economic reforms.

However N only thinks about the next election. Despite good performance in the energy sector, it has failed to provide gas for winter requirements as well as failed to increase exports and rejuvenate the economy to generate self made cash.

In the end the true benefits of CPEC will only arrive when we place equal if not greater effort towards economy.

The modern world has changed the landscape drastically and battles are now fought less on the war front and more on the economic and political front. You can have the largest army in the world but it won't mean squat if you don't have the economy likewise economic nations hold far more sway than militarized nations.

Pakistan must also realize the potent weapon economy is and how it can benefit its international standing as well as its military evolution.
 
Well said @saiyan0321

  • The largest infra development prior to CPEC took place under Ayub with the A-Pak [American-Pak] funding. Pakistan failed to leverage A-Pak. Let's hope CPEC is leveraged.

  • Pakistan needs to move away from militaristic thinking and focus on economics. Learn from the Chinese. Let CPEC and Chinese influence leads to "slash/burn" of the present mafia economy and that offers a chance for new saplings to take root in the economy that are hardy and ready to compete with the world instead of hiding under state protection. PIA, Pak Steel etc etc.

  • Pakistan needs to move away from acting like a guardian of Islam. It has been around thousand years before Pak became a reality. It is safe without Pakistan acting like a "Uncle Religion"".
  • Pakistan needs to focus on basics. Leave Israel, Jerusalam, Rohingya, Somali pirates please. Can we have quality schools, clinics, hospitals, police provision in every neigbourhood in Pakistan. Every child should get free school meal. Sell the freakin Pak Navy ships if you have to. Please feed and educate the little children of Pakistan.

  • Pakistanis are a resilient people. Even with terible governments we the people have busted ourselves and millions gone abroad to keep our familes fed. We may not have Tata's or Birla's but our common people. The dirt of the soil. They are our strength. Unlike 100s of million of Indias Dalits our "dirt" struggles and succeeds in feeding our families.

This is what I love about our people. We are like algae and take root anywhere. I was in Barcelona earlier in the year and had a proper Pakistani food in middle of Barcelona. The Pakistani cafe owner refused to accept any money. - https://www.dawn.com/news/1376378#toc_0
 
Last edited:
Well said @saiyan0321

  • The largest infra development prior to CPEC took place under Ayub with the A-Pak [American-Pak] funding. Pakistan failed to leverage A-Pak. Let's hope CPEC is leveraged.

  • Pakistan needs to move away from militaristic thinking and focus on economics. Learn from the Chinese. Let CPEC and Chinese influence leads to "slash/burn" of the present mafia economy and that offers a chance for new saplings to take root in the economy that are hardy and ready to compete with the world instead of hiding under state protection. PIA, Pak Steel etc etc.

  • Pakistan needs to move away from acting like a guardian of Islam. It has been around thousand years before Pak became a reality. It is safe without Pakistan acting like a "Uncle Religion"".
  • Pakistan needs to focus on basics. Leave Israel, Jerusalam, Rohingya, Somali pirates please. Can we have quality schools, clinics, hospitals, police provision in every neigbourhood in Pakistan. Every child should get free school meal. Sell the freakin Pak Navy ships if you have to. Please feed and educate the little children of Pakistan.

  • Pakistanis are a resilient people. Even with terible governments we the people have busted ourselves and millions gone abroad to keep our familes fed. We may not have Tata's or Birla's but our common people. The dirt of the soil. They are our strength. Unlike 100s of million of Indias Dalits our "dirt" struggles and succeeds in feeding our families.

This is what I love about our people. We are like algae and take root anywhere. I was in Barcelona earlier in the year and had a proper Pakistani food in middle of Barcelona. The Pakistani cafe owner refused to accept any money. - https://www.dawn.com/news/1376378#toc_0


Agreed to every word but would like to highlight two very important parts.

Pakistan needs to move away from acting like a guardian of Islam. It has been around thousand years before Pak became a reality. It is safe without Pakistan acting like a "Uncle Religion"

This. One of the most ridiculous slogans in pakistan is the call that Islam is in danger in pakistan. Sorry but that is not true. Islam was not in danger when its practitioner was only one man and its not in danger when 1.5 billions and 55 countries follow it. The very essence of the slogan is wrong.

I have highlighted again and again that we made enemies for Muslim brothers who later on turned against us and we helped the brethren that was openly against us. We cannot continue to damage ourself under the guise of ummah unity.

In fact I have argued that if you want to strengthen islam then the Muslim nations must strengthen themselves and islam would automatically become strong.

Pakistan should simply focus on its economic development and its human development.

Pakistan needs to focus on basics. Leave Israel, Jerusalam, Rohingya, Somali pirates please. Can we have quality schools, clinics, hospitals, police provision in every neigbourhood in Pakistan. Every child should get free school meal. Sell the freakin Pak Navy ships if you have to. Please feed and educate the little children of Pakistan.

One of the most dire things that worry me is the diminishing research culture. A country that loses its research culture, ceases to exist.

Pakistan does simply require proper budgets for health and education but it requires educational reforms. Our school system is orchestrated to crest robots that do ratta rather than encourage creative thinking and this lack of creative thinking has created a vacuum in our cultural evolution and cultural works as well as diminish the scientific research.

Normally nations evolve scientifically and we were progressing in 60s but we regressed and regressed badly and so much that a sanctioned country run by religious clerics publishes more papers than us.

We will tall about Israel when we publish more papers than them and have more progress and economic and political clout than them.

There is so much to repair in pakistan and all of this requires serious reforms but all we are doing is shutting up the capital under rumors and a change of "oath" to " undertake".

Not just that but we also need to bring madrassahs under state control and have them as proper educational institutes.

For all of this, we need strong governments and bold governments that will take the necessary steps. I personally don't see anyone.
 
This. One of the most ridiculous slogans in pakistan is the call that Islam is in danger in pakistan.
For 200 years before 1947 we had Sikhs rule us, we had British rule us. Yet Islam prevailed in 1947. Now that we are 98% Muslim majority and free from Sikh or British rule Islam is in danger. Absurd !

diminishing research culture
That is of a concern but honestly I would like to see every child between 5-16 in school geting basic maths, literacy, science and every child recieves free school meals that are impregnated with vitamins/minerals. Then focus on 16-18 by having two three streams.

* Higher level science/maths [Try to squeeze as many in this cohort]
* Higher level arts [try to reduce this cohort]
* Vocational education along the lines certified by German TUV. [Try to get every youth to get this]

* Focus on university/post grad education
* Focus on health service [emphasis on female reproductive health/education]
* Focus on sanitation/clean environment
* Focus housing stock [emphasis on cheap housing]
* Focus on policing [massive investment in men/equipment, stations, pay etc]

To finance all this place immediate cap on defence budget. Reduce Pak Navy size in increments. Reduce Pak armour forces. Increase tactical nuclear forces. Place emphasis on nuclear deterance as the nations shield.
 
How much of the problem is just structural? Is government doing a good job of capturing revenue (taxes and fees)? Is the government effective in serving both its citizens and businesses?
 
How much of the problem is just structural? Is government doing a good job of capturing revenue (taxes and fees)? Is the government effective in serving both its citizens and businesses?

Sir, Pakistani "government" and words like "good job" "capturing revenues" "effective" and "serving" simply do not go together these days. At all.
 
At present SBP of Pakistan has more than $14 bn of FX reserves and including commercial bank reserves touches $19.8 bn so the article is outdated
 
Pakistan’s foreign currency reserves held by State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) stand around $15 billion only, even after being jacked up by $2.5 billion received through bonds. It can meet three months’ imports bill.

If they further deplete by $5 billion, it can only meet roughly two months’ of import bill, pushing the country into danger zone. And if your reserves come down to $ 10 Billion again in the next five to seven months period then Pakistan will have no choice but knock the IMF door with a begging bowl. (Max Jul/Aug 2018) You can only pray it doesn't happen.

Pakistan’s central bank will already be having sleepless nights due to weakening debt repayment capacity. Pakistan’s interest-servicing burden remains extremely heavy as a share of fiscal revenue. The interest expense consumes nearly a third of your gov.t revenue. Credit ratings of Pakistan will only improve, if your country’s security environment settles to friendly & peaceful for investments & growth. Inadequate infrastructure, mainly in transportation and energy, acts as further bottlenecks to foreign direct investments

At IMF, they don’t know how to portray Pakistan’s economy, as a negative report from the staff of the fund will accelerate the depletion of foreign currency reserves, while a positive report will promote ‘inaction’ among policy makers, paving the way for meeting the same fate after a pause of few months.

I have been warning you from more than a year now. You have just 2-3 years for a civil unrest & anarchy to prevail. You are heading for a collapse, if you don’t make peace with India. After 2023 not only Kashmir, the entire Pakistanis will be at the mercy of India like Palestine. At the present rate you will run out of money & will power to fight the increasing terrorism in coming years leave alone fighting India or defending Kashmir.

Pakistan will have no choice in coming years rather than surrender to India. All your 75 years of struggle & bloodshed will eventually result in the loss of Kashmir to India. Do it today & may be you will get some hope & energy to turn around your country’s fate. It’s already too late. I know you won't & what frustrated replies will follow.

Whether you like it or not this is going to be your fate. Only time will hit you with reality. I have given dates. And I will be around.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom