What's new

History of Sindhis

I think , If you go back in history, you will find that all the south punjab (where siraiki live) was Sindh and because of being in the neighborhood of Punjabi speakings their language got effect of Punjabi (siraiki is mixture of Sindhi and punjabi) so in this way the siraiki language came into existence but siraiki speakers are ethnically sindhis speaking a language resembles to Sindhi and punjabi Languages both..

Even in Sindh many sindhis speak siraiki language too
 
I was thinking , Siraiki is a dialect of sindhi .
Can understand 85-90% of it
Can understand 10-20% of it nor can vast majority of saraikis understand it

Punjab, saraiki issue is post pakistan one A- to break power of power of Punjab in Pakistan by creating new identities of cultures that are a bit different than mainstream Punjab but exaggerate them and make new identities, hindko, saraiki and recently potohari
B- ever since Ranjit Singh every ruler of Punjab has suffered from Lahore centerism disease - Sikh, British and post pakistan CM's all have focused on Lahore= Punjab

This 200-300 years long neglect of other areas resulted in grievances being exploited paving way for new identities
Appears theirs lots of disagreement on the origin of siraki speakers !
 
Last edited:
"Punjab, Sindh, Gujrat, maratha, Dravid utkal bhang"
We have Sindh in our national anthem.
****-you-surprise.gif

Thanks for the info - no one asked
 
View attachment 867365

Sindh ko nazar lag gai kisi ki

Effects of hanging Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto

Punjabi, Pashtun, and muhajir youth make up the bulk of PTI

However, I don't see Sindhi or Baloch youth voting PTI. They are more secular and don't buy into "Pakistaniyat".

Pakistan is more of a North/South divide than ethnic one.

recently potohari

There's an interracial couple on tik tok, and the girl is hispanic and both the guy and girl call the language the guy speaks as "pothwari"

So I don't think Pakistan is trying to create new identities if people are saying stuff themselves.
 
Last edited:
I think , If you go back in history, you will find that all the south punjab (where siraiki live) was Sindh and because of being in the neighborhood of Punjabi speakings their language got effect of Punjabi (siraiki is mixture of Sindhi and punjabi) so in this way the siraiki language came into existence but siraiki speakers are ethnically sindhis speaking a language resembles to Sindhi and punjabi Languages both..

Even in Sindh many sindhis speak siraiki language too

Indigenous tribes of south punjab are similar to upper punjab. British had documented them. Seraiki is also more like majhi and potohari punjabi then sindhi.

Sindhi is political identity in which they have forced upon all living in Sindh of non-muhajir origin to adopt it. So all pathan, baloch, punjabis in interior sindh identify as Sindhis. Im talking about old migrants here. You will find pashtun durranis in Sindh or punjabi tribes like kharal/sial speaking sindhi and identifying with Sindh though they do know where they came from. Sindhi is also imposed on people that speak like seraiki in north part of sindh, or Tharis that speak more like Rajasthanis etc

Just like baloch and dravidian brahui became one in Balochistan to increase numbers combined politically vs pashtuns.

Also half of Sindhis are not even indigenous but mustly baloch. Sindhi nation suffer from trauma for that reason and is worried about yet again being taken over.

Effects of hanging Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto

Punjabi, Pashtun, and muhajir youth make up the bulk of PTI

However, I don't see Sindhi or Baloch youth voting PTI. They are more secular and don't buy into "Pakistaniyat".

Pakistan is more of a North/South divide than ethnic one.



There's an interracial couple on tik tok, and the girl is hispanic and both the guy and girl call the language the guy speaks as "pothwari"

So I don't think Pakistan is trying to create new identities if people are saying stuff themselves.

There is Tajik movement in North KP where they claim to be in millions that have adopted pashto but now are discovering their real origin.

So yes establishment is trying to create new identities in Kp and Punjab.
 
Last edited:
Sindhi nationalists are retarded. Imagine Pashtun nationalists being led by Rana Sanaullah. That’s effectively what Sindhis are prescribing to with Zardari and the PPP...

Zardari(ethnic Baluch) is like a symbiotic parasite that has latched onto and is feeding off the Bhuttos as his host.

:lol:
 
Sindhi nationalists are retarded. Imagine Pashtun nationalists being led by Rana Sanaullah. That’s effectively what Sindhis are prescribing to with Zardari and the PPP...

Zardari(ethnic Baluch) is like a symbiotic parasite that has latched onto and is feeding off the Bhuttos as his host.

:lol:

Zardari even said in an interview his mother tongue is Saraiki.
 
There's an interracial couple on tik tok, and the girl is hispanic and both the guy and girl call the language the guy speaks as "pothwari"

So I don't think Pakistan is trying to create new identities if people are saying stuff themselves.
It's just a dialect of Punjabi, not really an identity. Even if it's slightly different to the mainstream version of the culture, it's more of a sub-identity of Punjabi.

For example how Pashto dialects differ based on locality/tribe like Waziri, Quetta, etc.
 
ignore the India part
- Sindh was home to extensive trade networks and pirates controlled/influenced by King Dhahir
- Bin Qasim came from Iran (fars), Baluchistan through a land route
- King accepted Ssasanid loyalist into his court fleeing from the arabs in Persia which Ummiyads didn't appreciate
- A ship full of gifts for the caliph from Sri lanka were seized by Sindh based pirates - this triggered hostility
- First incursion was through sea by a different general
- He was defeated
- Kingdom was deeply internally divided with as a result little central authority
- Caliphates greatest asset was the internal support hey received from within the kingdom
- Tribes lived Semi autonomously
- Jutts and Meds from Baluchistan lived along the coast as traders, pirates and fishermen
- The Jutt people were repressed wearing of silk clothing banned, banned from carrying swords for fears of a rebellion, to enforce these rules the children of Jutt clan leadership were held hostage
- By the time MBQ was planning an attack coastal regions of Jutts and meds were in a state of turmoil/ rebellion with little central authority left
- After the first defeat, army reassembled, gathered new troops from syria, Fars and marched through land from Makran Baluchistan
- first attack on a Baloch coastal city
- Diebal was besieged, trenches dug in by MBQ and Hajaj bin Yousaf sent siege equipment through sea
- City conquered and sacked
- Jutt and meds people joined his campaign for revenge
- Sehwan attacked, Leader retreated, decided to do a night raid with thousand soldiers and jutt people who were still loyal to sindh
- failed
- sindh west of the indus became part of caliphate
- Sehwan revolts and kicked out its arab garrison - later repressed
- Hijaj orders a retreat to thata unable to cross the indus
- from thatta crossed the indus
- in the north near nawabshah a great battle was fought, first sindhi were winning but than tide turned resulting in MBQ victroy
- Dhahirs priest kept advising him BS
- Final battle 20k dhahir, 15k MBQ
-elephants charge, initially battle favored dhahir, arab forces were pushed back, great damage but as levied/ peasantry started retreating leaving only the noble horsemen to protect dhahir resulting in MBQ victory
 
View attachment 842677
History of the Hurs: Sindh

The Hurs were and are the main tribe living in this area. A proud and fierce people, the Hurs had given the British a difficult time. They had rebelled during World War II against British rule [1] During the British rule, Pir Pagaro declared his community “Hur” (free from British slavery). The British tried to crush the uprising and that started an armed resistance by Hurs. Ultimately the British passed the infamous law “Hur Act” where the entire Hur community was declared criminals and were ordered to be shot to death on sight

The Hurs cannot be said to have been defeated as they continued their struggle even after the hanging of the Pir Sahib, right up to the time of the independence of Pakistan, Pakistan having acquired the status of an independent country. The British were forced by Hurs and a number of other movements to leave the ‘Jewel in the British Crown’. Pir Pagaro Sayyed Sibghatullah Shah was hanged on March 20, 1943 and the British left Pakistan in four years’ time on 14th of August 1947. Long after the end of British rule, Pir Pagaro’s two sons, who were in British custody in England, were released and came back to lead their community. Sindh was a province in the newly independent Pakistan. The sons of Sibghatullah Shah Shaheed were brought to Pakistan in December 1951 after long negotiations. The elder son, Pir Sikandar Shah, Shah Mardan Shah, became the new Pir in February 1952. Shah Mardan Shah II is the current Pir Pagaro

Hurs in the 1965 War
At the time of the 1965 War the spiritual leader of the Hur was the Pir Pagaro.
The Hurs had earlier not joined the Pakistan Army in any numbers, however with the coming of war, thousands volunteered to fight against the Indians. The Hurs were (due to constraints of finances as well as time) given only basic training and armed with light weapons such as machine guns and assault rifles. The militia was placed under the Pakistani military and para-military forces operating in the sector (known collectively as the “Desert Force”). The Hur militia was commanded by the Faqir Jamal Mangrio.

The battle
The war began on 6 September 1965 and the hostilities in this sector commenced on September the 8th. Initially the Desert Force and the Hur was placed in a defensive role, a role for which they were well suited as it turned out. The Hur were familiar with the terrain and the local area and possessed many essential desert survival skills which their opponents (and indeed their comrades in the Pakistan Army) did not. Fighting as mainly light infantry, the Hur inflicted many casualties on the Indian forces as they entered Sindh. The Hurs were also employed as skirmishers, harassing the Indians LOC, a task they often undertook on camels. As the battle wore on the Hurs and the Desert Force were increasingly used to attack and capture Indian villages inside Rajasthan. It was in this vein that an assault on Kishangarh fort was launched. The attack surprised the Indians and the fort was carried after several days of bitter fighting.

Impact
The use of the Desert Force and the Hurs established a break in the traditions of the Pakistani army. While the Pakistani Army (and its predecessor the British Indian Army) had often used local auxiliaries for scouting and other durties, this was the first time that irregular forces were used on such a wide scale. The capture of this fort gave Pakistan several bargaining chips during the subsequent Tashkent Conference.

In 1965 war of India and Pakistan, the Southern desert sector was a mere sideshow to the major battles fought in the Punjab and in Kashmir. However the Indians had placed two divisions in the desert with the aim of tying down Pakistani troops.

Facing a shortage of troops and unable to divert any substantial forces from the Punjab and Kashmir sectors (where the main Indian thrust has come), the commander of the Pakistan Rangers, Brigadier Khuda Dad Khan, turned to local help. Hurs volunteered in droves. Given only basic training and light weapons, the Hurs nevertheless gave a fine account of themselves in the conflict. Fighting alongside Rangers and regular army units (known collectively as the Desert Force), the Hurs used their knowledge of the desert to good effect and helped to blunt the Indian offensive. But, perhaps their most famous (and militarily important) action was the capture of the Indian fort of Kishangarh, a feature located several kilometers inside India

The capture of the Kishangarh in Rajasthan State India took place during the 1965 War between India and Pakistan. Its capture was one of the most important actions of the Desert Theater in that war and one of the finest examples of the use of local militia in the history of the Sub-Continent.

Background
The outpost is around 11 kilometers (Lat 27.871 N,Lon 70.563 E) inside Indian territory, in the so called Jaisalmer Bulge. It is a small mud Structure 70 by 60 meters across. It sits 22 km east of the town of Tanot towards the International border. It also sits on the only road linking any part of Rajasthan with the Pakistani city of Rahim Yar Khan.

The Desert Sector was a mere sideshow in the 1965 Indo-Pakistan War. Both sides had little experience in desert fighting at the time, and moreover the main industrial, and economic heartland of Pakistan and India were to the north. As a result when war came the Indians main effort would be against Lahore and Sialkot in the Punjab. However the Indians left some forces in the region with the aim of launching local offensives. Pakistani army troops in the region were already very stretched, having to defend a sector nearly a thousand km in length. To counteract this effort, the commander Pakistan Army Rangers asked the local people for help

Persecution of Hurs by Bhutto Government
In 1972 Zulfikar Ali Bhutto became the president and then the prime minister of Pakistan. Under his government, the Government of Sindh started a crackdown on Hurs. Matters got worst when four prominent fakirs were gunned down by police. Their photos appeared in the newspapers as dacoits gunned down by police in armed combat.This happened despite the fact that Sindhies considered Hurs as Sindh’s heroes and the historic Bhutto family personally respected Pir Pagaro. In the general elections of 1977, Pir Pagaro decided to break the tradition of not becoming involved in power politics and ran for the seat of parliament from Mr. Bhuttos hometown of Larkana. This was a symbolic gesture of protest but Pir Pagaro was arrested. This saw a bloody clash of Hurs and government leaving hundreds of Hurs and government officials dead


Creation of Hur Force
In 1977 coup which overthrew Mr. Bhutto, the newly empowered dictator General Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq, who was looking for some foothold in Sindh, restored the status of Hurs in Pakistan Army. He also appointed a famous Sindhi civil servant Mr. Bashir Ahmed Siddiqui as the Inspector General of Sindh to face the growing problem of dacoits, especially Paro Chandio. Mr. Siddiqui formed a militia called Hur Force out of Hurs. This saw the death of 1965 war hero Faqir Jamal Mangrio by the hand of Paro Chandio but also saw the death of Paro Chandio by the hand of I.G. Siddiqui himself


Persecution of Hurs by Benazir’s Government
In 1988, President Zia-ul-Haq died in an air crash and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto’s daughter Benazir Bhutto was elected as Prime Minister. Benazir Bhutto’s government decided to replace the Hur Force with a new force called Magsi Force, consisting of militants from the tribe of Mir Nadir Ali Magsi, a rival of Hurs. Benazir Bhutto encouraged and supported clash between forces and after bloody clashes the Hur Force was weakened substantially.


UNTOLD STORY:::::

Local people have found large amounts of wood in the bed of the Chotiari Reservoir, Sanghar district, after the water level in the reservoir reached dead level. Elders of the area believe that the big trees which are visible now in the reservoir once constituted the historic Makhi Forest, which was a hideout for the Hur Tahreek fighters before the Partition


“It was the center of the Hur resistance movement against the British rule (over India) under the command of Pir Sibghatullah Shah Rashdi, a spiritual leader,” said 65-year-old president of the Hur Historical Society Sanghar, Mir Nizamani

He told The News that before the Chotiari reservoir was built the place was known as the Baqar Lake, a cluster of several freshwater lakes, and the Makhi forest used to be near it.


He provided details that when the British army in retaliation bombed a village, Jadoopur, still located at a sand dune in the middle of the reservoir, killing some people, including a woman, the Hur fighters had to change their strategy. They made a cut in the major Nara Canal, due to which water inundated a wide area and most of the travel routes were blocked. It was the year 1942-43, the Hur fighters led by Rahim Hingoro hid in the Makhi forest, he added


The reason to adopt this strategy was that most of the villages inhabited by the resistance fighters or their supporters were located at sand dunes and these artificial floods would not allow the British forces to harm the residents, Nizamani said. He added that the cut in the Nara Canal inundated the forest area and turned it into a number of water lakes.

Moreover, he said that since the Hur elders were either killed on the battlefield or put into concentration camps with their entire families by the British government, remaining families in the area migrated to other areas. By the time the concentration camps were abolished and the people languishing in those camps were released, the Hur population was scattered to different locations. “And nobody knew where the Makhi forest had gone,” Nizamani added


@SABRE @jus_chillin @Talwar e Pakistan @Aijaz Kolachi @Daghalodi @Jf-17 block 3 @Super Falcon
For British they were gangsters, for us they were and are heroes
 
Sindhi Women prepare clothes for the refugees in the Government House Karachi, 1947. Fatima Jinnah and wife of Sindh Governor Mrs. Zubeida Habib Ibrahim Rahimtoola are also visible in the background.
20230703_220219.jpg
 
One thing about Sindhis-
They were never the same guys. In the early ages, Sindhi were dark people. Then came invasions after invasions, and with each Irani and central Asian invasions, they went from darker to lighter-skinned. Their languages also changed from one invasion to another invasion.

Yes Bronze Age Indo-Aryans were indeed white people. They merged with dark-skinned natives of the Indus, giving birth to Sindhis and other Indo-Aryan groups.
 

Back
Top Bottom