What's new

Indian Inventions throughout the ages

Status
Not open for further replies.
Pakistan for Pakistanis and india for indians.

Yeah, you chose not be Indians, which is really a far bigger thing than anyone isolated part of the subcontinent, let alone the part you guys inherited.
 
how about this:

Pakistanis are Indian Muslims who were mislead by Jinnah, the false messiah. Incidentally, he was an Muslim Indian who thought he had different culture and history just because he chose to follow a particular faith.
 
Pakistan for Pakistanis and india for indians.

So, please don't claim Indo-Islamic Urdu and buzz off from here. Indo-Islamic culture is culture of North Indian Muslims who's mother tongue is Urdu, the Bengali Muslims, the Mappilas etc. Pakistani culture is the culture of Punjabi Muslims, Sindhi, Pashtun and Balochis and Urdu is the alien term for Pakistani culture. Urdu is 100% Indian the heritage of 65 Million Muslims of 11 States/UT of India.
 
how about this:

Pakistanis are Indian Muslims who were mislead by Jinnah, the false messiah. Incidentally, he was an Muslim Indian who thought he had different culture and history just because he chose to follow a particular faith.

I know your text books tell you to hate Jinnah but it was not him who caused Pakistan to happen but instead it was Nehru.

Jinnah wanted a united India was autonomy for the Muslim majority areas so as to protect them and their culture.
Nehru, being a socialist, could not digest this. And thus Pakistan was born.
You have no one to blame but Nehru.

---------- Post added at 10:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:55 PM ----------

So, please don't claim Indo-Islamic Urdu and buzz off from here. Indo-Islamic culture is culture of North Indian Muslims who's mother tongue is Urdu, the Bengali Muslims, the Mappilas etc. Pakistani culture is the culture of Punjabi Muslims, Sindhi, Pashtun and Balochis and Urdu is the alien term for Pakistani culture. Urdu is 100% Indian the heritage of 65 Million Muslims of 11 States/UT of India.

Dude you need to relax.
maybe take a break and get some warm milk or something
 
how about this:

Pakistanis are Indian Muslims who were mislead by Jinnah, the false messiah. Incidentally, he was an Muslim Indian who thought he had different culture and history just because he chose to follow a particular faith.

We were never indians and will never be indians. And the Quaid is one of the greatest leaders this world has ever produced.

---------- Post added at 06:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:57 PM ----------

So, please don't claim Indo-Islamic Urdu and buzz off from here. Indo-Islamic culture is culture of North Indian Muslims who's mother tongue is Urdu, the Bengali Muslims, the Mappilas etc. Pakistani culture is the culture of Punjabi Muslims, Sindhi, Pashtun and Balochis and Urdu is the alien term for Pakistani culture. Urdu is 100% Indian the heritage of 65 Million Muslims of 11 States/UT of India.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
seethru said:
:hitwall:
delete
delete

know its quite off topic but the discussion on this thread has already become off topic.why not add some more off topicism.
 
I know your text books tell you to hate Jinnah but it was not him who caused Pakistan to happen but instead it was Nehru.

Jinnah wanted a united India was autonomy for the Muslim majority areas so as to protect them and their culture.
Nehru, being a socialist, could not digest this. And thus Pakistan was born.
You have no one to blame but Nehru.

---------- Post added at 10:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:55 PM ----------



Dude you need to relax.
maybe take a break and get some warm milk or something

1. India Doesn't need its children to be indoctrinated, so the text books here do not have hero worship of warriors and dynastic rulers and distortions in the history if Independence. This ain't pakiland. so pls shut it. stop attributing same **** that happens in pak to India.

2.Protect Muslims? from whom? evil Hindus?

3. We don't hate Jinnah. we simply consider him a politician who lost his way and slightly dull in History. he could be a great leader to you but a mediocre politician to many.
 
Again Pakistan is ours and india is yours - keep this in mind, and celebrate whatever is on indian soil and we have no problem with it.
 
We were never indians and will never be indians. And the Quaid is one of the greatest leaders this world has ever produced.

---------- Post added at 06:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:57 PM ----------




I think you got screwed up because you have no answers because Urdu is an Indo-Islamic culture and not the part of Pakistani-Islamic culture. Please come back with some answers instead of Bullshit videos , I also have some videos for you like this one.



---------- Post added at 07:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:43 PM ----------

Again Pakistan is ours and india is yours - keep this in mind, and celebrate whatever is on indian soil and we have no problem with it.

And Urdu language is ours.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Urdu, unlike the popular myth....never belonged to " pakistan". If you want a claim to fame, you may accept it as a shared inheritance.
 
Urdu, unlike the popular myth....never belonged to " pakistan". If you want a claim to fame, you may accept it as a shared inheritance.

Definitely, 80% of Native Speakers of Urdu live in India. Who speak it, the Migrant Muhajirs who still bears the tag of Refugees means Urdu is the language of Refugees for Pakistanis and 95% Pakistanis have no connection with it. How come it become language of Punjabis when they are speaking Punjabis since ancient times even after converting to Islam. Urdu is "Ganga-Yamuna Tehzeeb" and not the "Indus Tehzeeb"

Pakistani culture means Punjabi-Sindhi culture.
 
I am a Punjabi but I have only known Urdu my entire life.
What is a "native Urdu speaker" any ways?
If it is someone who has spoken it since birth then I would say that 80% of Pakistanis are native urdu speakers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom