What's new

India's Space Success 'LIMITED' but offers lessons: Chinese Media

$@rJen

BANNED
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
6,326
Reaction score
-21
Country
India
Location
Israel
Shear jealousy compels China to call India's Space Success as 'LIMITED'
Thursday, February 16, 2017
By: India Today

Source Link: CLICK HERE

  • 4_img116217093232.jpg
  • 4_img116217093232.jpg
  • 4_img116217093232.jpg


A Chinese state-run newspaper in an editorial Thursday said India's record of sending 104 satellites into space was "a limited achievement", with India's space programme still lagging behind China's successes in its manned space programme.

India on Wednesday launched a record 104 satellites on a single rocket, which followed the Mars orbiter mission, which also garnered attention in China. The Chinese government described the Mars orbiter mission as "the pride of Asia" and said it would be keen to work more closely with India on space projects.

The state media, however, struck a different note on Thursday. "The Indians have reason to be proud," said a Thursday editorial in the Party-run Global Times, a widely read tabloid. "However, the space technology race is not mainly about the number of satellites at one go," it added. "It's fair to say the significance of this achievement is limited. In this regard, Indian scientists know more than the Indian public, who are encouraged by media reports."


INDIA'S SPACE PROGRAMME VERSUS US, CHINA ::

The editorial pooh-poohed where India's space programme stood in comparison to America's and China's. "India's space technology development tends to project national image. It's reported that India also plans to reach Venus, another programme that is suitable for media hype but lacks follow-up research," the editorial said.

"On the whole, India's space technology still lags behind the US and China's. It has not yet formed a complete system. For instance, the engine of its rockets is not powerful enough to support large-scale space exploration."


WHERE IS INDIA LAGGING BEHIND ::

The editorial pointed out, "There is no Indian astronaut in space and the country's plan to establish a space station has not started," referring to China's manned space missions, with two astronauts last year spending 30 days in the Tiangong-2 space module, which will be developed into a full-fledged space station.

The paper did add that it was "a hard-won achievement for India to reach current space technology level with a relatively small investment", saying it offered "food for thought for other countries", pointing out that the US space budget in 2013 was $39.3 billion, China $6.1 billion, Russia $5.3 billion, Japan $3.6 billion and India $1.2 billion.

The editorial concluded that India's example was "worth pondering". "The first is its ambition to make India a great power. Therefore, it's focused not only on immediate interests but long-term ones. Second, the country believes it should remain present in space technology development, given its close links with military. And third, India is under pressure to compete with China and refuses to lag behind."

"India's Achilles' Heel is its relatively small economic scale and a weak foundation for national development. As a hierarchical society, it has both world-class elite and a largest number of poor people. Many lessons can be drawn from India. As a rising power, it has done a good job. It is ambitious but pragmatic, preferring to compare with others as an incentive to progress. India's political and social philosophy is worth pondering.
 
Shear jealousy compels China to call India's Space Success as 'LIMITED'
Thursday, February 16, 2017
By: India Today

Source Link: CLICK HERE

  • 4_img116217093232.jpg
  • 4_img116217093232.jpg
  • 4_img116217093232.jpg


A Chinese state-run newspaper in an editorial Thursday said India's record of sending 104 satellites into space was "a limited achievement", with India's space programme still lagging behind China's successes in its manned space programme.

India on Wednesday launched a record 104 satellites on a single rocket, which followed the Mars orbiter mission, which also garnered attention in China. The Chinese government described the Mars orbiter mission as "the pride of Asia" and said it would be keen to work more closely with India on space projects.

The state media, however, struck a different note on Thursday. "The Indians have reason to be proud," said a Thursday editorial in the Party-run Global Times, a widely read tabloid. "However, the space technology race is not mainly about the number of satellites at one go," it added. "It's fair to say the significance of this achievement is limited. In this regard, Indian scientists know more than the Indian public, who are encouraged by media reports."


INDIA'S SPACE PROGRAMME VERSUS US, CHINA ::

The editorial pooh-poohed where India's space programme stood in comparison to America's and China's. "India's space technology development tends to project national image. It's reported that India also plans to reach Venus, another programme that is suitable for media hype but lacks follow-up research," the editorial said.

"On the whole, India's space technology still lags behind the US and China's. It has not yet formed a complete system. For instance, the engine of its rockets is not powerful enough to support large-scale space exploration."


WHERE IS INDIA LAGGING BEHIND ::

The editorial pointed out, "There is no Indian astronaut in space and the country's plan to establish a space station has not started," referring to China's manned space missions, with two astronauts last year spending 30 days in the Tiangong-2 space module, which will be developed into a full-fledged space station.

The paper did add that it was "a hard-won achievement for India to reach current space technology level with a relatively small investment", saying it offered "food for thought for other countries", pointing out that the US space budget in 2013 was $39.3 billion, China $6.1 billion, Russia $5.3 billion, Japan $3.6 billion and India $1.2 billion.

The editorial concluded that India's example was "worth pondering". "The first is its ambition to make India a great power. Therefore, it's focused not only on immediate interests but long-term ones. Second, the country believes it should remain present in space technology development, given its close links with military. And third, India is under pressure to compete with China and refuses to lag behind."

"India's Achilles' Heel is its relatively small economic scale and a weak foundation for national development. As a hierarchical society, it has both world-class elite and a largest number of poor people. Many lessons can be drawn from India. As a rising power, it has done a good job. It is ambitious but pragmatic, preferring to compare with others as an incentive to progress. India's political and social philosophy is worth pondering.

Of Course we are far behind the US .
But China is also nothing in front of US .

Chinese can cry but we dont care .
Human Space Flight or a manned station is not a bench mark .We can do all of this but that is not our goal.
 
what is the heaviest satellite india has put to orbit?
and what was the main payload for this launch?

As far as I know, the INSAT-3DR (2211 Kg) launched through GSLV Mk II is the heaviest successful satellite launch by ISRO.

Also, ISRO did launch successfully the experimental vehicle for manned mission, Crew Module Atmospheric Re-entry Experiment (CARE) in 2014, weighing 3775 kg using GSLV MK III.

During first quarter of 2017, ISRO planning to launch GSAT-19E satellite weighing 3200kg.
 
Iddia: We carried out most successful mission to moon till date.

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: We are planning to explore sun and making a satellite for that.

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: We are making SAR satellite with NASA and It willhave resolution in mm.

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: W are planning a mission to Venus.

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India:.We are planning to bring down launch cost to just 10%

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: We carried out mission to mars in first attempt. We are first to do that

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: We tested scramjet engine

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: We are most cost effective launcher of satellite.

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: We have carried out test of space shuttle and we shall use it againand again to launch satellite.

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: We launch mini hubble sort of satellite which solve a 100+ years old space mistry

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.

India: We launched 104 satellite from one rocket.

China: We have a rocket which can carry heavy pay load.
 
Last edited:
Well these chinis think they got the best space tech in asia while time n again they beaten by Japanese and Indian in many front.Manned Mission is not a priority for both nation , does that make both a lesser one than china.
 
Well these chinis think they got the best space tech in asia while time n again they beaten by Japanese and Indian in many front.Manned Mission is not a priority for both nation , does that make both a lesser one than china.


Ya they carried it out with Russian technology with nothing their own.
 
And we gave a "LIMITED" eff to jealous Chinese.
 
Shear jealousy compels China to call India's Space Success as 'LIMITED'
Thursday, February 16, 2017
By: India Today

Source Link: CLICK HERE

  • 4_img116217093232.jpg
  • 4_img116217093232.jpg
  • 4_img116217093232.jpg


A Chinese state-run newspaper in an editorial Thursday said India's record of sending 104 satellites into space was "a limited achievement", with India's space programme still lagging behind China's successes in its manned space programme.

India on Wednesday launched a record 104 satellites on a single rocket, which followed the Mars orbiter mission, which also garnered attention in China. The Chinese government described the Mars orbiter mission as "the pride of Asia" and said it would be keen to work more closely with India on space projects.

The state media, however, struck a different note on Thursday. "The Indians have reason to be proud," said a Thursday editorial in the Party-run Global Times, a widely read tabloid. "However, the space technology race is not mainly about the number of satellites at one go," it added. "It's fair to say the significance of this achievement is limited. In this regard, Indian scientists know more than the Indian public, who are encouraged by media reports."


INDIA'S SPACE PROGRAMME VERSUS US, CHINA ::

The editorial pooh-poohed where India's space programme stood in comparison to America's and China's. "India's space technology development tends to project national image. It's reported that India also plans to reach Venus, another programme that is suitable for media hype but lacks follow-up research," the editorial said.

"On the whole, India's space technology still lags behind the US and China's. It has not yet formed a complete system. For instance, the engine of its rockets is not powerful enough to support large-scale space exploration."


WHERE IS INDIA LAGGING BEHIND ::

The editorial pointed out, "There is no Indian astronaut in space and the country's plan to establish a space station has not started," referring to China's manned space missions, with two astronauts last year spending 30 days in the Tiangong-2 space module, which will be developed into a full-fledged space station.

The paper did add that it was "a hard-won achievement for India to reach current space technology level with a relatively small investment", saying it offered "food for thought for other countries", pointing out that the US space budget in 2013 was $39.3 billion, China $6.1 billion, Russia $5.3 billion, Japan $3.6 billion and India $1.2 billion.

The editorial concluded that India's example was "worth pondering". "The first is its ambition to make India a great power. Therefore, it's focused not only on immediate interests but long-term ones. Second, the country believes it should remain present in space technology development, given its close links with military. And third, India is under pressure to compete with China and refuses to lag behind."

"India's Achilles' Heel is its relatively small economic scale and a weak foundation for national development. As a hierarchical society, it has both world-class elite and a largest number of poor people. Many lessons can be drawn from India. As a rising power, it has done a good job. It is ambitious but pragmatic, preferring to compare with others as an incentive to progress. India's political and social philosophy is worth pondering.

what is the big deal if it is limited ? who cares ??
 

Back
Top Bottom