Fatima Jinnah : How current Pakistan evaluates her

[haman10]

She was half persian , a Shia by faith .. Is that why you support her ?
Most of the Pakistanis believe that she was not sincere to her country

bhai , i dont support anyone just because they are "persian" !!

there are hundreds of thousands of "persian" people that i think are not even worth spitting on !

and p.s she was half-persian as u mentioned . i support her because pakistani people support her (today i found out not all of them )

still its your country . of course i love pakistan but i can never claim that my love is even close to you ppl . you know the best for pakistan and i want the best for pakistan .

these are different things .

still i dont think she is a looter and deserved being killed in a terrorist attack getting shot in the head .

long live pakistan

 

[Jf Thunder]

She was awesome
She was a Shia too , like Muhammad Ali Jinnah
no one dislikes them for their sect

lol, who said they were Shia lol they were muslims


and i read a quote somewhere and no i cant give a source cuz i dont know where i read it, but i know its true, i will try to find it here is the quote like i remeber

once Mr Jinnah was asked "are you Shia or Suni?"
he replied "What was our Holy Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.W)
the reporter replied "he was a muslim"
Mr Jinnah said "then i am a muslim too"

 

[Armstrong]

i really dont understand what she did !!

seriously !! sure ma'am jinah was not comparable in greatness . but calling bhutto a looter is anything but fair

Are you telling me that you'd know more about Pakistani Politicians than Pakistanis ?

Well think of it this way Bhutto's hubby was called Mr.10% because the word was that he'd take a 10% cut-out of every Government Project & her Government was dismissed on charges of corruption the first time around !

And then when after her death, her Party got a lot of sympathy vote & came to power in the previous Elections, her Hubby became El-Presidente of Pakistan & his Government managed to rake up more debt in their 5 years than the past 60 combined without a single mega project to show for !

Whereas Fatima Jinnah - Our Mother is dearly loved by us as she dearly loved us all & had she lived this country - our Pakistan - would've been so....so much different because she believed & understood better than anyone why we fought for Pakistan, what our dreams were & what Our Father wanted for us !

 

[M. Sarmad]

lol, who said they were Shia lol they were muslims


and i read a quote somewhere and no i cant give a source cuz i dont know where i read it, but i know its true, i will try to find it here is the quote like i remeber

once Mr Jinnah was asked "are you Shia or Suni?"
he replied "What was our Holy Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.W)
the reporter replied "he was a muslim"
Mr Jinnah said "then i am a muslim too"

Here is the marriage certificate of jinnah which says he was a Shia :

 

[Leader]

3 pages and basically everyone chanting she was our mother, and nothing else, probably none of us really know about her much.. you guys should read about her sometime...

 

[haman10]

Are you telling me that you'd know more about Pakistani Politicians than Pakistanis ?

no dearest brother i am sorry read my post after that :

still its your country . of course i love pakistan but i can never claim that my love is even close to you ppl . you know the best for pakistan and i want the best for pakistan .

 

[Capt.Popeye]

who is this fatima jinnah ..wife of jinnah or his daughter ????

Neither. She was his Sister.
Jinnah's wife was a Parsi, Ruttonbai. She was daughter of Sir Dinshaw Petit of Bombay.
Ruttie and M.A.Jinnah had only one child, a daughter named Dina; who was born on 15th August 1919. She opted to live in India. She later married Neville Wadia of the famous Wadia Family of the Bombay Dyeing Group of Industries in India. Her son Nusli Wadia is the present Chairman of the Group.
She lives in Switzerland and India now. She has laid claim to Jinnah's residence "South Court" on Malabar Hill in Mumbai as her ancestral property.

 

[W.11]

Neither. She was his Sister.
Jinnah's wife was a Parsi, Ruttonbai. She was daughter of Sir Dinshaw Petit of Bombay.
Ruttie and M.A.Jinnah had only one child, a daughter named Dina; who was born on 15th August 1919. She opted to live in India. She later married Neville Wadia of the famous Wadia Family of the Bombay Dyeing Group of Industries in India. Her son Nusli Wadia is the present Chairman of the Group.
She lives in Switzerland and India now. She has laid claim to Jinnah's residence "South Court" on Malabar Hill in Mumbai as her ancestral property.

and lady mount batten was the mother of india u forgot to mention and now sonia is mother of india

Here is the marriage certificate of jinnah which says he was a Shia :

this shia/sunni thing is BS

 

[M. Sarmad]

this shia/sunni thing is BS

It really is
But unfortunately it exists

 

[Armstrong]

Neither. She was his Sister.
Jinnah's wife was a Parsi, Ruttonbai. She was daughter of Sir Dinshaw Petit of Bombay.
Ruttie and M.A.Jinnah had only one child, a daughter named Dina; who was born on 15th August 1919. She opted to live in India. She later married Neville Wadia of the famous Wadia Family of the Bombay Dyeing Group of Industries in India. Her son Nusli Wadia is the present Chairman of the Group.
She lives in Switzerland and India now. She has laid claim to Jinnah's residence "South Court" on Malabar Hill in Mumbai as her ancestral property.

I thought it was New York !

And Rattanbai converted to Islam !

 

[Kompromat]

Mother of the Nation.

 

[Armstrong]

u mean she reverted?

Reverted ?

Reverted would imply that she was a Muslim who converted to something else before reverting back to Islam !

 

[M. Sarmad]

And Rattanbai converted to Islam !

She converted because Jinnah being a Muslim could not marry a parsi woman as per British law

 

[airmarshal]

she challenged the ayub khan's dictatorial rule and rigged presidential elections, she was the only one

all the fake politicians who consider themselves champions of democracy once stood with the dictators and mocked her

She was one of the founding members of this country. Yet she was ridiculed to the point of humiliation. They were the forefathers of our current politicians.

Ayub did a lot of good to our country, but when it comes to self preservation these generals are no less selfish than politicians. Fatima Jinnah exposed this trait and thats her biggest contribution, at least to me, after creation of Pakistan.

@W.11! Honestly no offense meant here. But after posting this 'Z.A. BHUTTO: ENEMY OF DEMOCRACY (PART I)', do you or your party MQM has any scruples? Any morality, any shred of principle to be in alliance with Bhutto's party for so long? Your leader calling Benazir his sister? Although that sister was as corrupt as his brother in law Zardari.

 

[W.11]

im against title of mother father, there is an entire team work which is always behind

personality worship should stop

also jinnah died too soon, he never laid contitution like washington laid american constitution