What's new

Give Agricultural Land to Poor

then you are communist.
RIP logic. @ThunderCat I found your soulmate, I present you not a neoliberal but a full-fledged libertarian. :D
Restricting land annexation is the same as being a communist?

As early as the 16th century B.C., Dong Zhongshu, a minister of Emperor Liu Che of the Han Dynasty of China, enacted a law restricting land annexation and setting a ceiling on individual land ownership. By your logic, was the Han Empire the first Soviet regime?

Why limit land annexation? Because if there is no restriction on land annexation, those who hold the power will inevitably continue to annex more and more land, and more and more landless peasants will become de facto serfs dependent on them. The holders of power and large quantities of land will solidify the upward and downward movement of social classes, denying opportunities to talented people at the bottom of the ladder, and ultimately leading to increasingly stupid regimes. The holders of power and land will also use their power to gain privileges to evade and avoid taxes, ultimately weakening the entire nation and the state. The life of the people at the bottom will become more and more difficult, and they will not have a sense of belonging to the country and the nation if they do not see any hope. In the event of a foreign enemy or a large-scale natural disaster. These people at the bottom will rebel or commit treason.
Even Canada is now starting to restrict people regarding the purchasing of properties and Canada will now be considered a communist country according to this guy lol.
 
All the repeat failed plans of Capitalism like Trickle Down Economy and Banana Republic are being applied again and again in Pakistan.

"American author O. Henry coined the term to describe Honduras and Costa Rica under economic exploitation by U.S. corporations, such as the United Fruit Company (now Chiquita).[1] Typically, a banana republic has a society of extremely stratified social classes, usually a large impoverished working class and a ruling class plutocracy, composed of the business, political, and military elites.[2] The ruling class controls the primary sector of the economy by way of the exploitation of labor;[3] thus, the term banana republic is a pejorative descriptor for a servile oligarchy that abets and supports, for kickbacks, the exploitation of large-scale plantation agriculture, especially banana cultivation.[3]"

 
People always have a rosy and rainbow picture in their head of how things will just fall magically into place if people were simply given a fair start.

Unfortunately things are not always as simple. Farming isn't an easy job and it doesn't take much to lose everything if there is drought or flood. It isn't cheap and it's a lot of hard work that requires patience and accepting setbacks.

As people have mentioned it is more likely many of these new farmers will cash out and take their chances on something else.

I remember a story in the US about giving people new houses for almost nothing so they wouldn't be homeless and get a fresh start on life. Well many simply sold them for the quick cash.

That "great idea" solved nothing.
Yeah as a farmer i have seen many such people who got things for free, just selling them off and then continue to waste that money until they are back to square one.
Especially in a highly volatile market like Pakistan, only farmers with some (backbone) survives!
 
Last edited:
Yeah as a farmer i ahve seen many such people who got things for free, just selling them off and then continue to waste that money until they are back to square one.
Especially in a highly volatile market like Pakistan, only farmers with some (backbone) survives!
Sale should be banned of such lands. Only rights for growing crops and utilizing the land should be given. Corporate farms can also be sold due to Pakistan's conditions. K-Electric has been sold three or four times already.
 
Sale should be banned of such lands. Only rights for growing crops and utilizing the land should be given. Corporate farms can also be sold due to Pakistan's conditions. K-Electric has been sold three or four times already.
itr has been done too, it doesnt work.
 

Back
Top Bottom