INDIAN NSG COMMANDO's vs SSG PAKISTAN!

[batmannow]

INDIAN NSG COMMANDO's vs SSG PAKISTAN!
WHO IS THE BEST?
both failed in , the recent counter terrorism, opreations!
pakistan ssg, doesnt comeup good in LAL MASJID episode.
indian nsg commando's , also not been good in mumbai ?

why, what should be done to make them , more good?


plz open your minds, give your thoughts on the issue, but dont be calling personal shots.

thanks

 

[Imran Khan]

what boss now our indian members will say there NSG win and you already batmanow fail our SSG not good

 

[Vinod2070]

I am not sure. There was a delay in their deployment but they conducted their brief with a great success.

The mission was very delicate and tough in view of the large buildings and the hostage situation.

 

[batmannow]

what boss now our indian members will say there NSG win and you already batmanow fail our SSG not good

imran khan; sir
let them say something, we can wait for them, later can discuss with good points, the truth we have to accept , to become the best!

 

[smeaglegolum]

I don't want to comapare them because they have faced different situations/circumstances. May be it is better to compare their weapons, training methods etc. Here is a link for NSG of India

National Security Guard

 

[QADRI]

Ya circumtances are different....the number of Armed Personals in Lal Masjid and Taj Hostel is different...moreover situation is also quite different...In case of India there was a hotel and in case of Pakistan there is a mosque loaded with heavily armed Personals.

 

[Vinod2070]

While I congratulate batmannow on a great topic, I doubt this comparision can be done really objectively. The forces operate in secrecy.

I am sure both are very good and highly competent, among the very best in the world.

 

[XYON]

The comparison cannot be done as one is Army Special Forces (SSG) and other other is a Paramilitray Special Force (NSG). The roles, operational existence, equipment, deployment philosophy etc etc are different although the Army SSG may sometimes be used for MOUT and semi-Urban assaults. Whereas Paramilitary forces such as NSG are exclusive to civilian and urban roles and no militray role.

Good comparison will come if you compare the US Special Weapons & Tactics (SWAT) Squad to the Indian NSG! Unfortunately, Pakistan does not have a comparable paramilitray force such as the NSG!

 

[Kasrkin]

Actually think we do, something along the lines of Elite Rangers but sadly I don't remember their exact designation.

 

[Imran Khan]

i thamb up both they are best both finish terarrst are recover there land from that inocent killers.and we can see both are well aquipted because both can take any thing wich they need

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Thread closed.

These kinds of 'vs' threads are pointless.

Feel free to discuss (training, equipment, missions etc.) the respective units in their own threads.