Why India is an illegitimate nation

[ST1976]

Take a look at the western border in this map, it’s a sadly ignored part of history that if it wasn’t for sikhs pushing punjab border that far west afghans would still rule till indus.

also, its shows Rule of Sikh on Lahore including Peshawar and Multan upto 1839 to 1849.
since fall of Marath by 1820
.
=>
the Third Anglo-Maratha War (1817–1818) resulted in the loss of Maratha independence. It left the British in control of most of the Indian subcontinent. The Peshwa was exiled to Bithoor (Marat, near Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh) as a pensioner of the British.

Maratha Empire - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[ST1976]

What veto power ?

Russia is part of P5s of UN, with Veto, and Delhi-Moscow-Tehran share this together, with other means of Moscow having since SU's time, since Cold war

 

[TheSolution]

A failed nation telling others who are 30 to 40 years ahead of them in education, development, and every sphere of economy. Tell me a field where you are ahead of us.

You are definitely not 30-40 years ahead.

Maybe 10 years max. In fact in some areas Pakistan's issue isn't even capability, it's severe incompetency and proper policy, simply not taking things seriously.

 

[nahtanbob]

You are definitely not 30-40 years ahead.

Maybe 10 years max. In fact in some areas Pakistan's issue isn't even capability, it's severe incompetency and proper policy, simply not taking things seriously.

You cannot fix illiteracy overnight. there is a huge difference in outcomes between kids of literates and kids of illiterates getting the same education.

 

[ST1976]

You cannot fix illiteracy overnight. there is a huge difference in outcomes between kids of literates and kids of illiterates getting the same education.

US is the sole Super Power of the world in true sense.
You attack any American ally and you will have Americans fighting with their whole might against you.
Russia,China and India have very little true-alliance building behaviour.They are mostly business oriented dealers.
They will never be able to compete US when it comes to building alliances.
And alliance is what that builds a solid block to set a world order.

China despite its military might is afraid to come out of its shell and build alliance with anti-US countries and challenge the US hegemony.
Russia is simply exhausted now.
India's approach is always careful.
They will never take risk
Typical Subcontinental behaviour.

Chinese are old buddies thanks to their one child Policy.they can't expend their men to build their influence on the world.

Russia is a giant gas station owned by oligarchs.

Russia military innovation has been close to zero post Cold War.

Russian military industrial base has been declining slowly

Educated Russians have been migrating. The population is stagnant.

we find India-Russia-Tehran combined power increased consistently since 1990

 

[my2cents]

We are ahead in our plans for first use.

We should be in our own race to reduce poverty, unemployment and illiteracy. We should be fighting together to eliminate these things in our countries, not spread more hatred. Healthy competition is good for us.

 

[ST1976]

We should be in our own race to reduce poverty, unemployment and illiteracy. We should be fighting together to eliminate these things in our countries, not spread more hatred. Healthy competition is good for us.

No, that's not what PPP means.
It means that the purchasing parity within the country is a lot higher.
This is due to the low cost of Labour and low living standards in India, which means that a lot more can be purchased for the same amount, theoretically making the average person better off on paper, but not when you have a colossal population like India.

You've again proven that India suffers from a colossal amount of poverty due to the massive value of its PPP economy within the nation and that a lot more can be bought for a lot less due to the higher value of currency to the average person.

Of course this is going to be lower in the UK where the currency value for the average person is lower due to the higher prices of commodities and services due to having a much more advanced educational and operational system, which leads to much higher competition in demand and therefore better living standards in the long run

You should be counting GDP PER CAPITA.

Overpopulated countries like India will always rank at the top.

Compare with China, who has a similar population as yours, and look at the piss-poor gau mutra showing.

And Comparing London, Shanghai, Beijing and HongKong with Mumbai is like comparing your kaamwali bai to Aishwarya Rai.

Not even in the same league as infra, city services, convenience to access parts of the city and a hundred other things.

I know it looks good in Swarajya Mag, but come the f*ck on !!

Stay limited within India.

Don't make me post pictures of Dharavi slums - which should be enough.

how you people think of Philippines, the NIC member as below? are the countries like Philippines able to feed themselves?
here we have table of NIC, current. we find GDP on PPP per Capita of India is close to Philippines-Indonesia, have a close look on the table as below.

Newly industrialized country - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

here i would say, India-Philippines-Vietnam-China might be having similar ratio of 'undocumented' part of GDP

 

[El Sidd]

you said you have nothing to lose. I said it is a country with 250 million people. That is a lot to lose.

Are the 250 million worthless and useless ? Those are your words. I never said that. That is a different topic for debate.

Why are you so focused about the losing part, i also said Pakistan has everything to gain. That also counts for 250 million people.

We should be in our own race to reduce poverty, unemployment and illiteracy. We should be fighting together to eliminate these things in our countries, not spread more hatred. Healthy competition is good for us.

Pakistan cannot solve your societal issues like Islamophobia, misplaced religious revanchism and quite abhorrent understanding of social justice.

 

[my2cents]

Pakistan cannot solve your societal issues like Islamophobia, misplaced religious revanchism and quite abhorrent understanding of social justice.

We should solve our own problems with help from law enforcement agencies and like minded people. No one is above law. Our constitution is there for the people. Work within its ambit.

 

[arjunk]

We should be in our own race to reduce poverty, unemployment and illiteracy. We should be fighting together to eliminate these things in our countries, not spread more hatred. Healthy competition is good for us.

Hard to do this when you send clowns like Jadhav and Abhinandan to blow up schoolchildren, or issue monthly threats to ivnade Pakistan

 

[El Sidd]

We should solve our own problems with help from law enforcement agencies and like minded people. No one is above law. Our constitution is there for the people. Work within its ambit.

Like minded people just seems like a fancy word for an own mob. The so called law enforcement agencies for example the police are in some cases chief organisers of communal form of justice as envisioned by your society.

 

[my2cents]

Like minded people just seems like a fancy word for an own mob. The so called law enforcement agencies for example the police are in some cases chief organisers of communal form of justice as envisioned by your society.

If chief ministers can be put in jail, then police are nothing. They all answerable too. Is it perfect, no. But you have to work with what you have.
Your people were involved in recent attacks on your minorities. Mobs burned down 5 churches and scores of Christian homes. I don't know if your police were complacent about providing security. You should be more aware of the problems we both face.

 

[El Sidd]

If chief ministers can be put in jail, then police are nothing. They all answerable too. Is it perfect, no. But you have to work with what you have.
Your people were involved in recent attacks on your minorities. Mobs burned down 5 churches and scores of Christian homes. I don't know if your police were complacent about providing security. You should be more aware of the problems we both face.

Cute excuse from someone who has genocidal lunatics like Modi and Yogi running the country.

 

[Musings]

Looked at the title of the thread and then the OP - remarkable that the thread has lasted so long.
Nonsense title - nonsense thread

 

[ST1976]

That just shows an unequal distribution of wealth. Moscow on the other hand has an average high income lifestyle. While Mumbai has a slum right next to ambani house.

We should be in our own race to reduce poverty, unemployment and illiteracy. We should be fighting together to eliminate these things in our countries, not spread more hatred. Healthy competition is good for us.

You should be counting GDP PER CAPITA.

Overpopulated countries like India will always rank at the top.

Compare with China, who has a similar population as yours, and look at the piss-poor gau mutra showing.

And Comparing London, Shanghai, Beijing and HongKong with Mumbai is like comparing your kaamwali bai to Aishwarya Rai.

Not even in the same league as infra, city services, convenience to access parts of the city and a hundred other things.

I know it looks good in Swarajya Mag, but come the f*ck on !!

Stay limited within India.

Don't make me post pictures of Dharavi slums - which should be enough.

No, that's not what PPP means.
It means that the purchasing parity within the country is a lot higher.
This is due to the low cost of Labour and low living standards in India, which means that a lot more can be purchased for the same amount, theoretically making the average person better off on paper, but not when you have a colossal population like India.

You've again proven that India suffers from a colossal amount of poverty due to the massive value of its PPP economy within the nation and that a lot more can be bought for a lot less due to the higher value of currency to the average person.

Of course this is going to be lower in the UK where the currency value for the average person is lower due to the higher prices of commodities and services due to having a much more advanced educational and operational system, which leads to much higher competition in demand and therefore better living standards in the long run

here we have news as below, India is among nations who give 'free Ration/food' to 2/3rd population, if they exercise their rights in India

what about other South Asian nations? do they offer the same for their poor? how many countries in world where poor don't sleep hungry? it cost India budget around $30bil per year
.
=>

Free ration to the poor will be extended for 5 years, 80 crore will benefit: Modi​

"During Covid-19, the biggest concern of the poor was what they would feed their children... Then I decided that I will not let any poor sleep hungry, hence the BJP government started the Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Anna Yojana," PM Modi said.​

Free ration to the poor will be extended for 5 years, 80 crore will benefit: Modi

"During Covid-19, the biggest concern of the poor was what they would feed their children... Then I decided that I will not let any poor sleep hungry, hence the BJP government started the Pradhan Mantri Garib Kalyan Anna Yojana," PM Modi said.

indianexpress.com

.

=> https://www.businesstoday.in/latest...for-next-five-years-pm-modi-404558-2023-11-04

BJP-led Centre to extend free ration scheme for 80 crore poor for next five years. PM Narendra Modi made the announcement at a rally in Chhattisgarh. According to government officials, this move will incur an expenditure of approximately Rs 2 lakh crore.